English 43505

Gender Troubles: Contemporary Irish Fiction

 

Spring 2012

12:30-1:45pm

108 DeBartolo Hall

 

Susan Cannon Harris


Contact Information:

 

Susan Cannon Harris

220 Decio Hall

University of Notre Dame
Notre Dame, IN 46556

Email: sharris2@nd.edu

Office phone: (574) 631-5088

Website: http://www.nd.edu/~sharris2/

Web address for this syllabus: http://www.nd.edu/~sharris2/43505.htm

 

Office Hours: T Th 10:00-11:30am or by appointment


DESCRIPTION


In this course we will be looking at the relationship between gender politics and national politics as it plays out in the development of Irish fiction after the era of James Joyce. Focusing on Irish novels and short stories which were groundbreaking and/or controversial in terms of their exploration of gender and sexuality, the course will also investigate the historical contexts in which they were produced and the controversies they produced. Our investigation will focus on the question of how the 'trouble' generated around these controversial explorations of gender and sexuality relates to other kinds of trouble that have shaped the history of twentieth century Ireland. We will begin with the reaction against government censorship in the Irish Free State during the 1930s and 1940s, and follow the emergence of Irish women writers, Irish feminism, and gay and lesbian Irish writers. 


Required Texts


The Gathering. Anne Enright.

A Green and Mortal Sound: Short Fiction by Irish Women Writers. Ed. Louise DeSalvo.

The Country Girls Trilogy. Edna O’Brien.

The Land of Spices. Kate O’Brien.

The Dark. John McGahern.

At Swim, Two Boys. Jamie O’Neill.

 

Course packet available in 131 Decio (later, 301 O’Shaughnessy)

 

Electronic reserve.

 

Occasional handouts.


Coursework and Policy Statement


 

READING

 

You are responsible for reading everything mentioned on the syllabus unless I specifically tell you otherwise. (I will update the course outline on the web as it changes and notify you of changes via email; please check your email regularly.) Because most of class time will be spent working with the reading, failure to do the required reading will hurt you, your group, and the class in general. It will also lower your in-class work grade.

 

ATTENDANCE

 

Because this class places a tremendous importance on student interaction, your presence and participation are crucial to the well-being of the class as a whole. Attendance is mandatory. If you miss ten minutes or more of a class, that counts as an unexcused absence.

 

The only excuses for absence that I accept are religious holidays, physical or mental illness (verified by the appropriate health care professional), or serious emotional trauma. I will allow one unexcused absence for the semester free of charge; after that, your in-class work grade drops 25 points with each unexcused absence. If you have four unexcused absences you will fail the course. I will notify you if you are in danger of failing due to absences.

 

WRITING

 

You will write one major seminar paper of 15-25 pages, which will be submitted to me electronically before 8:00am Friday, May 11. There will be shorter assignments to prepare you for this paper.

 

Reading Journals.

 

You will keep a reading journal, which you will turn in once a week. (Half of you will turn it in on Tuesdays; half of you will turn it in on Thursdays.) The reading journal has three purposes: 1) to encourage you to engage with the reading assignments before coming to class to discuss them, 2) to provide you with a place to work out your ideas about the seminar paper before you begin to write it, and 3) to give me a sense of how you are responding to the reading. The reading journal requirements are as follows:

 

 

Reading journal entries must be turned in in hard copy on time or they will not be accepted. Individual entries are given a credit/no credit mark and written feedback. You will not receive credit for entries that do not meet the basic requirements (i.e., do not deal with that day’s reading, do not show that you are caught up on the reading, do not engage in a thoughtful manner with the text, are less than a full page long, or are late). If you do not turn in a journal entry on time, or it does not receive credit, you will get a zero for that week. Your “credit rating” for your journal accounts for 5% of your final grade. The amount of effort you put into your reading journal will be factored into your course participation grade. Save your journal entries when you get them back, because you will be asked to resubmit them along with your final paper. Due dates for the journal are not listed on the syllabus.

 

Statement of Interests.

 

Midway through the semester you will write an 3-5 page essay in which you identify and discuss the issues or questions that have most interested you, and identify research topics that you might wish to pursue in your seminar paper. This will give you a chance to focus your ideas before you have to actually begin writing the paper, and it will give me an opportunity to make suggestions about what to look for as you begin planning for your research paper.

 

Topic Proposal and Bibliography.

 

Several weeks before your final paper is due I will ask you to turn in a 3-5 page topic proposal and bibliography explaining what your final paper will be about and listing works you plan to use.  

 

Draft.

 

Before the final paper is due I will require you to turn in a complete draft. I will give it back to you with feedback that will help you revise, but you will not be graded on it. However, doing the draft is a basic requirement of the course. If you fail to turn the draft in on time, or if your draft is not complete, your final paper will be docked a full letter grade. If you NEVER turn in a draft, your final grade for the COURSE will be docked a full letter grade.

 

A draft is “complete” if it fulfills the requirements of the assignment. The rule of thumb I use is that if you could hand the paper in as it is and still receive a passing grade, then it's a complete draft. If the draft is, for instance, three pages long, or does not respond to the assignment, or was obviously written between 4:00 a.m. and 4:45 a.m. that morning in a burst of last-minute, caffeine-fueled desperation, then the draft is incomplete.

 

All assignments will printed out and turned in at the beginning of class on the days they are due. If you are absent on the day that an assignment is due, even if your absence is excused, it is your responsibility to make sure it somehow gets to me at or before class begins that day.

 

Short assignments—journals plus the statement of interests and topic proposal and bibliography—must be turned in on time or they will not be accepted. Unless I ask you to turn your work in electronically, all assignments must be handed to me on hard copy at the beginning of class on the day on which they are due. If your draft is turned in late, your final paper will be docked a full letter grade. If you turn your final seminar paper late, it will be docked a full letter grade for every day it is late. For instance, if you turn your final paper in after 5:00 on the day it is due, it will be considered half a day late and your final paper will be docked half a letter grade--an A will go down to a B+, etc. If your paper is due on Tuesday, and it is turned in at 8:00 am Wednesday, it will be docked a full letter grade: an A goes down to a B, and so on. When the sun rises on Thursday morning, that A paper is a C; a C paper is an F. The clock does not stop on weekends; if the final paper is due Friday and I get it Monday, it is three days late and will be docked accordingly.

 

Papers must be double-spaced throughout (except for block quotations and footnotes). Include page numbers. Margins should be no wider than 1.25" on the right and left and 1" on the top and bottom (standard setting on most word processors). The font size must be 12-point. Papers that do not meet these requirements will be docked half a letter grade. All papers must include a title, the number of the assignment, your name, my name, and the date.

 

PRESENTATIONS

 

At the beginning of the semester I will divide you into research groups. Each group will be responsible for leading one class discussion. Your research and preparation (documented in a bibliography and lesson plan) will be assessed along with the actual presentation and discussion of the assigned text(s) in class to determine your group's overall grade. Everyone in your group will receive the same grade.

 

PLAGIARISM

 

Plagiarism--attempting to pass off someone else's writing as your own--is a serious offense and will not be tolerated. All outside sources must be cited correctly and in accordance with MLA guidelines. This goes for your drafts, journals, and short assignments as well as the major papers. If I find evidence that you have plagiarized any part of any assignment, I will prosecute you to the fullest extent allowable by the Academic Honor Code.  

 

If at any point you are uncertain about whether you may have plagiarized from a source you used, please ask me about it before turning in the paper.

 

CONFERENCES

 

Unless I have notified you in advance, I will always be available in my office during my office hours for conferences. If you can't make those hours you can always set up an appointment with me for another time.

 

GRADING

 

Your final grade for the course breaks down as follows:

 

Seminar paper: 60%
Presentation: 10%
Statement of Interests and Topic Proposal/Bibliography: 15%
Class participation: 15%

 

The paper, presentation, statement of interests and topic proposal/bibliography will be assigned letter grades. Journals will be marked credit/no credit. Your reading journal credit rating will account for 1/3 of your class participation grade, or 5% of your final grade for the course. 

 

The remaining 2/3 of your class participation score is based on your attendance, the quality of your reading journal, your contributions to group work, your contributions to class discussion, and your conduct in the classroom.

 

While in this classroom, you are required to treat everyone else with respect at all times. Failure to do so will significantly lower your in-class work grade.


 


Course Outline


This syllabus is subject to change. I will inform you of any changes in advance.


I.  Sex, Violence, and The Censorship, 1924-1942


Week One: Battle And The Sexes


January 17

 Introduction

 

January 19

Handout:

A Brief History of Ireland Before Partition

Liam O’Flaherty:

“The Sniper,” “Civil War,” “Spring Sowing,” “Milking Time”


Week Two: Scandals 


January 24

Handout or course packet:

A Somewhat More Detailed History of Ireland After Partition

Electronic Reserve:

Sean O’Faolain: “Midsummer Night Madness,” “The Small Lady”

 

January 26

Course Packet 1-18, 40-53:

Selections from The Problem of Undesirable Printed Matter

Addresses to men and women from Dublin Eucharistic Congress of 1932


Week Three: Evil Literature


January 31

Kate O’Brien, Land Of Spices (Part One: Rosary Sunday)

Course Packet:

George Herbert, “Prayer”

 

February 2

Kate O’Brien, Land Of Spices (Part Two: La Pudeur Et La Politesse)



 

Week Four: Something Understood


February 7

Kate O’Brien, Land of Spices (Part Three: June)

 

February 9

Handout:

Eibhear Walshe, “Banned: 1934-41”

Course Packet:

“New Novels” (Irish Times March 8, 1941);

Sean O’Faolain, “Standards and Taste,” “Our Nasty Novelists,” C. B. Murphy, “Sex, Censorship, and the Church,” “Censorship: Principle and Practice;” Monk Gibbon, “In Defence of Censorship”


II. Writing In The Dark, 1942-1969


Week Five: Safe Home?


February 14

Handout:

Selections from the Constitution of Ireland, 1947

Electronic Reserve:

James M. Smith, “The Politics of Sexual Knowledge:

The Origins of Ireland’s Containment Culture and the Carrigan Report (1931)”

 

February 16

Electronic Reserve:

Mary Lavin: “Sunday Brings Sunday,” “Sarah”


Week Six: Wild Irish Girls


February 21

Edna O’Brien, The Country Girls chapters 1-12

(3-112 in The Country Girls Trilogy)

 

February 23

Edna O’Brien, The Country Girls chapters 13-end

(112-175 in The Country Girls Trilogy)

Course Packet:

“The Lady’s Not For Burning”


Week Seven: Confessions


February 28

John McGahern, The Dark, Chapters 1-20 (7-126)

Electronic Reserve:

Michel Foucault, “The Incitement to Discourse”

 

March 1

John McGahern, The Dark, Chapters 21-31 (126-191)

Course Packet:

Point of View in The Dark


Week Eight: Limbo


March 6

 Electronic Reserve:

Mary Lavin, “The Lost Child”

 

March 8

Statement of Interests Due.

Film: Sex In A Cold Climate 


 March 11-17: Spring break.   


III. Comings Out, 1978-2007


Week Nine: Dirty Laundry


 March 20

DeSalvo: 31-38, 62-78, 244-257

Leland Bardwell, “The Dove Of Peace;” Eilis ni Dhuibhne, “Midwife To The Fairies;” Julia O’Faolain, “Melancholy Baby”

 

March 22

 Electronic Reserve:

Kathryn Conrad, “Fetal Ireland: Reproduction, Agency, and Irish National Discourses”


Week Ten: Another Country


March 27

Electronic Reserve:

Mary Dorcey: “A Noise from the Woodshed,” “Introducing Nessa

 

March 29

Jamie O’Neill, At Swim, Two Boys chapters 1-7 (3-152)


Week Eleven: Green Triangles


April 3

Jamie O’Neill, At Swim: Two Boys chapters 8-10 (153-249)

 

April 5

Jamie O’Neill, At Swim, Two Boys

Chapters 11-15 (250-369)


Week Twelve: Excess of Love?


April 10

Jamie O’Neill, At Swim, Two Boys

Chapters 16-18 (437-482)

 

April 12

Jamie O’Neill, At Swim, Two Boys

Chapters 19-22 (483-end)


Week Thirteen: Lost and Found


April 17

Anne Enright, The Gathering chapters 1-21(1-140)

 

APRIL 18

TOPIC PROPOSAL/BIBLIOGRAPHY SUBMITTED ELECTRONICALLY BY 5:00pm.

 

April 19

Conferences. No class.


Week Fourteen: Secrets and Lies


April 24

Anne Enright, The Gathering chapters 22-39 (141-261)

 

April 26

DRAFT OF FINAL PAPER DUE.


Week Fifteen


May 1

Drafts returned. Last class day.


PAPER #3 submitted ELECTRONICALLY by 8:00a.m. Friday, May 11