Preserve respect and integrity at Notre Dame
Jim Lee
sophomore
Editor's note: Because"The Vagina Monologues" contains some graphic content and offensive language, the letters discussing these issues will contain such language as well. In order to foster an intelligent dialogue on this matter, this language must be included. Readers who might be offended by such language are cautioned.
In his Feb. 15 letter, Mr. Tyszka emphasized the need for one to understand various views in order learn; indeed, this is necessary in any type of learning. However, this does not mean that Notre Dame, as a Catholic university, should endorse or sponsor a play such as "The Vagina Monologues." "Academic freedom" and "open-mindedness" should be encouraged at any University, but I do not believe a play such as "The Vagina Monologues" best addresses the real issues of lesbianism or femininity. I would much rather encourage those representing the lesbian community to offer a stance with respect and integrity rather than vulgarity.
Ms. McShane, in her Feb. 15, letter offered the idea that the "Monologues" is not about vulgarity, but rather about empowering women and their self-confidence. I strongly agree that all women should be confident in themselves. Yet a play such as the "Monologues" does not seem empowering to women at all; McShane spoke of the "common terms" males use freely in reference to their genitalia, and offered the idea that women should have this "confidence."
My question is, why would women want to stoop to that level? If one is attempting to promote confidence, shouldn't one do so by means of dignity, integrity and respect? The "Monologues" may strive to promote empowerment, but does so through offensive and vulgar means. Aren't there better ways for women to express themselves, such as chastity and independence?
In response to Mr. Tyszka, our University should strive for diversity, and as a Catholic University, should show love to all; indeed we should welcome all with love. However, Notre Dame should embrace a correct representation of them.
In addition, as a Catholic University, Notre Dame sets itself apart, with a level of moral responsibility that is unique. There are thousands of other schools that allow anything; Notre Dame is special in its claim to spirituality and integrity, and should therefore not endorse such a performance.
My challenge and question to Notre Dame: are you serious about the integrity and respect of Our Lady's University? Prove it.
Jim Lee
sophomore
Morrissey Manor
Feb. 17, 2002
All Viewpoint Stories for Monday, February 18, 2002
