Value open minds
Dan Tyszka
sophomore
My letter is in response to Sean Dudley's letter on Feb. 14. I guess it has to happen every so often that someone decides that he or she must change the University with a letter to The Observer.
Yesterday, Mr. Dudley chose to do this with an attack on the "Vagina Monologues," "academic freedom" and "open-mindedness." I already understand his issues with the "Monologues," but I am really confused with what is wrong with academic freedom and open-mindedness. I guess we could make this University a sheltered haven in which we can all share identical views of Christianity. We could, but we won't.
Mr. Dudley does not seem to understand that without various views, one does not learn, but rather just regurgitates a single person's thoughts.
I have recently read Chesterton's novel, "The Ball and the Cross," (I suspect we may even be in the same class), and I have to say that I believe my worthy opponent is in error. He really does not qualify the quotation and I am also left wondering if he wishes to challenge the writers and performers of the "Monologues" to a mortal duel. Chesterton was an avid proponent of Catholicism, but he also listened to opposing views, even embraced the arguments that they presented, as any true scholar would do.
See, in order for one to truly understand one's own views he must also understand those of this "opponent."
Mr. Dudley does not seem to realize that "academic freedom" and "open-mindedness" are what make Notre Dame a great place. All philosophies should be welcome here, including atheism and lesbianism as well as other philosophies with which he does not agree. Understanding is listening, and apparently some do not value the latter as others do.
I do not even wish to challenge his views on the offensive nature, as Mr. Dudley just does not seem open to anything. He is obviously an avid Catholic and cannot bear to hear anything said against Catholic doctrine. On that note, I would appeal to the University to continue its approach towards a diverse education and to even take greater strides to diversify Our Lady's University.
Dan Tyszka
sophomore
Sorin Hall
Feb. 14, 2002
All Viewpoint Stories for Friday, February 15, 2002
