|
Ph.D. In Literature
Course Descriptions
Spring 2003
Students can take a minimum of three courses and
a maximum of four, not including language acquisition courses. (Language
classes do not count toward the 9 credit.) Every effort should be
made to acquire language proficiency as early as possible. Please
bear in mind, the language exams will be rigorous and must be satisfied
by the end of the third semester of residence.
Students are required to consult with the Program
Director/and or Director of Graduate Studies prior to enrolling
in any course. Students should select their courses from the listings
described in this booklet. However, in special circumstances and
with prior authorization from the Program's Director and/or Director
of Graduate Studies, graduate level courses not listed here can
be taken for credit.
Students are reminded of the Program's requirements
in Core, Primary and Related Fields. With the advice of the Director/
Director of Graduate Studies, and/or advisors in their field students,
will, at the appropriate time, be expected to demonstrate what constitutes
Primary and Related fields of study.
Courses will be scheduled on the following days:
M = Monday
T = Tuesday
W = Wednesday
H = Thursday
F = Friday
TH = Tuesday & Thursday
Please note: this listing of courses may change for
various reasons.
REQUIRED COURSE:
WORLD LITERATURE
4812 LIT585A 01 Literary Theory - Philology
and Weltliteratur
M 1:30-4:15 Professor Joseph A. Buttigieg
The Literature Programs course on Literary Theory deals with theories
of different time and places with emphasis on the critical problems
that arise when what we call "Literature" is investigated
in a multicultural context. Issues that may be expected to arise
include the following the problems of translation, the meaning of
metaphor, hermeneutics complexity, the meaning of the word "style"
the relation between oral and written literatures.
Philology and Weltliteratur
Eric Auerbach's essay, from which this course derives its title,
serves as a point of departure for exploring the possibility of
developing an approach to literary history and literary interpretation
that: (a) attends to the historical, cultural and aesthetic specificity
of the individual literary work and (b) at the same time, brings
into relief the complex ways in which cultures interact, overlap,
and modify one another. The course will focus primarily on the pertinent
works of Vico, Herder, and the German Romantics, Auerbach (and other
historicists), Arnold, C. L. R. James, Raymond Williams, and Edward
W. Said, as well as selections from the writings of Fanon, Ngugi,
Lamming, Cesaire, and others.
Required Books:
| Author |
Title |
Publisher |
ISBN |
| G. Vico |
On the Study Methods of Our
Time |
Cornell Univ. Press |
0801497787 |
| J.G. Herder |
Philosophical Writings |
Cambridge Univ. Press |
0521794099 |
| J.J. Rousseau |
Discourse on the Origin of
Inequality |
Oxford World Classics: Oxford
Univ. Press |
0192829475 |
| B. Anderson |
Imagined Communities |
Verso Books |
0860915468 |
| A. Cesaire |
Discourse on Colonialism |
NYU Press |
1583670254 |
| E. Said |
Culture and Imperialism |
Vintage |
0679750541 |
| P. Gilroy |
The Black Atlantic: Modernity
& Double Consciousness |
Harvard Univ. Press |
0674076060 |
Recommended Books:
| Author |
Title |
Publisher |
ISBN |
| J.A. Hobson |
Imperialism |
Univ. of Michigan Press |
0472061038 |
| E. Habsbawm |
National and Nationalism Since 1780 |
Cambridge Univ. Press |
0521439612 |
| E. Said |
Orientalism |
Random House |
039474067X |
| S. Amin |
Eurocentrism |
Monthly Review Press |
0853457867 |
Course packet will be available in 336 O'Shaughnessy Friday,
January 13
SUGGESTED COURSES
5795 LIT 515L 01 Apuleius
T 2-5 Bradley, Keith
An investigation of the historical Apuleius. The course examines
the Romano-African context into which Apuleius was born, recreates
the educational travels to Carthage, Athens and Rome which occupied
his early life, and focuses especially on his trial for magic in
Sabratha in 158/9, before following him back to Carthage where he
spent the rest of his life. Notice will be taken of all of Apuleius'
writings, but special attention will be paid to the Apology, and
to the documentary nature and socio-cultural importance of the Metamorphoses.
The course is open to students with or without Latin.
5567 LIT 501 01 Literature and Religion
TH 11-12:15 Braungart, Wolfgang
Literature, according to Martin Walser, descends just as irrefutably
from religion as human beings do from the apes. Indeed, there is
no denying that even during aesthetic modernism, literature, art,
and religion are closely intertwined. When art achieved autonomous
status in the second half of the 18th century, it did, to be sure,
shed its subservient function relative to religion, yet in terms
of its topics, themes, and, most particularly, its claim to interpret
and give meaning to human existence literature remained tied to
religion, in fact became its great rival.
This seminar will examine several stations of this development.
Beginning with church hymns during the Renaissance and Barock, we
will see how the Bible was discovered as a literary text in the
18th century. At the end of the century, art is conceived as an
autonomous, even holy artifact. Poetry, for some, even becomes the
medium of human self-definition and the place in which new myths
are created. In the Romantic period art and religion become fused
into a single unity. A century later, art and religion again come
into close contact in lyric poetry of the fin-de-siecle. The seminar
concludes with a consideration of the psalm form in 20th-century
poetry. Readings will include works by Luther, Paul Gerhardt, Klopstock,
Hölderlin, Wackenroder, Stefan George, Rilke, Trakl, Brecht,
Celan, and Bachmann.
5572 LIT 521A 01 Poetry and Philosophy in the Twelfth Century
TH 2-3:15 Gersh, Stephen
This course will aim to provide a close reading of Bernard Silvestris'
"Cosmographia" and Alan of Lille's "De Planctu Naturae"
against the background of early twelfth-century philosophical thought
and grammatical-rhetorical theory. Although it will be initially
necessary to cover the philological and historical ground with some
care, the course will also attempt to explore in a more speculative
and creative manner the question of the kind of relation between
philosophy and literature in general that works like the "Cosmographia"
and "De Planctu" suggest. As stimuli to such reflections,
we shall pause to examine in some detail such textual phenomena
as the philosophical allegory, the hermeneutical and metaphysical
implications of number, the notion of self-reflexivity, and the
negative symbol. The course is intended to be accessible to students
without skill in Latin (although the latter would, obviously, be
an advantage). Requirement: one final paper of ca. 20 pp.
5646 LIT 555 01 Gaelic Gothic
TH 5-6:15 Gibbons, Luke
This seminar will discuss the development of the Enlightenment and
the Gothic in Irish culture in relation (i) to "internal"
excluded others - Catholics, Gaelic culture, (ii) questions of gender,
and, (iii) the diversity Irish responses, both at home and abroad,
towards other excluded peoples: African-Americans, indigenous peoples
in America and Australia, and other cultures on the receiving end
of Empire. As if affording a culture of consolation, Romanticism
and primitivism became a refuge for many "doomed peoples,"
(including the Celts), while the Gothic and racial theory provided
new modes of countering the threat on the "other" under
modernity. The seminar will begin with eighteenth century debates
focusing on 'the sublime' in Edmund Burke and the painter, James
Barry; the emphasis will then shift to the rise of the Gothic, questions
of cultural nationalism, and the emergence of Irish modernity, concentrating
on Joyce; and will finish with an analysis of how these concepts
have played out in cinema, especially the Irish-American cinema
of John Ford, and depictions of immigration in recent Irish films.
4765 LIT 529A 01 Canon & Literature
of Islam
TH 9:30-10:45 Afsaruddin, Asma
This course is an introduction to the religious literature of the
Arab-Islamic world. Emphasis is on works from the classical and
medieval periods of Islam, roughly from the seventh to the fourteenth
century of the common era. We will read selections from the Qur'an
(the sacred scripture of Islam), the Hadith literature (sayings
attributed to the prophet Muhammed), the biography of the Prophet,
commentaries on the Qur'an, historical and philosophical texts,
and mystical poetry. All texts will be read in English translation.
No prior knowledge of Islam and its civilization is assumed, although
helpful.
5570 LIT 565 01 Goethe and His Time
T 12:30-3:15 Norton, Robert
In this course we will examine some of the major works written during
the Classical period of German literature, between 1750 and 1830.
In addition to Goethe himself, we will focus on writings by Klopstock,
Lessing, Schiller, Hölderlin, Kleist, and Tieck. All readings
will be in the original, class discussions and presentations will
be in English.
5569 LIT 574 01 Minority German Writers
TH 9:30-10:45 DellaRossa, Denise
This course explores German-language literature written by authors
of non-German heritages. As a seminar it opens up the possibilities
of reading a more diverse body of post-1945, and more specifically
post-Wende, German literature. Secondary texts will help us to understand
the social and historical context in which these authors write.
The primary reading selections will include works by authors of
African, Turkish, Sorbian, Roma and Arab heritages.
5645 LIT 556 01 The Novel as an Agent of
Change
W 10-12:30 Doody, Margaret
The course title is suggested by Elizabeth Eisenstein's book title
The Printing Press as an Agent of Change. The Novel and the development
of print are often connected. Ian Watt's "Rise of the Novel"
is associated with the same period as that allotted to what we term
"the Enlightenment." This view of the history of the genre
may well seem defective, once we look at the novels of antiquity.
It might be truer to say that the novel as a genre has always served
as a means of what we can call "enlightenment," at various
stages of its being. The Novel has recently been valued as a mirror
of history, dealing with the manners and practices of persons within
a culture. But the Novel itself may be considered as "an Agent
of Change," not just a reflector of it. The Novel enacts the
processes (historical and psychological) of change and recognition.
Novelistic anagnorisis (recognition, or coming to know in a new
way) is not seeking a stable ending (as in the oversimplified version
of Aristotelian theatre) but enacting a process in which, after
every recognition, subsequent recognition must be absorbed. The
individual character has to interact with a multifaceted and changeful
world, without being allowed the leisure for lengthy abstract philosophical
reflection. (Indeed, what that individual may be is a novelistic
subject in itself.) As Philip Sidney and others have noted, fiction
comes between history and philosophy, offering us something different
from either though related to both. Novels are also (unlike most
traditional works of history and philosophy) often penned by outsiders,
foreigners, and women. If we want to know how and why we think both
personal and social change is possible, we should look first at
the Novel as the biggest and most pervasive cultural exemplar of
both cultural and personal metamorphosis.
We shall start by examining three major novels of antiquity: Heliodorus,
Aithiopika; Petronius, Satyricon; and Apuleius, Metamorphoses (The
Golden Ass or Asinus aureus). We shall then move to the Renaissance,
pursuing the first two books of Rabelais' set of five (now compendiously
termed Gargantua and Pantagruel) and the first part of Cervantes'
Don Quixote. Later texts include the following: Lafayette, The Princess
of Cleves (La Princesse de Clèves); Swift, Gulliver's Travels;
Richardson, Pamela (and selected passages of Sir Charles Grandison);
Graffigny, Letters of a Peruvian Woman (Lettres d'une Péruvienne);
Scott, Old Mortality and The Heart of Midlothian; Gaskell, North
and South.
5900 LIT 578 01 Nature/ID in SpanAm: Popul
vuh
T 12:30-3 pm Heller, Ben
We will trace the images and metaphors with which Spanish American
writers and interested foreign travelers have described Latin American
Nature. Earthly paradise, green inferno, a wasteland to be populated,
or most nurturing aspect of the "madre patria," these
images and others we will discuss have both reflected ideological
biases and shaped national cultures and identities. We will read
a diverse collection of texts (from the Popol vuh to Sarmiento's
Facundo to Neruda's Canto General) from the 19th and 20th centuries,
with a few incursions in key colonial texts (Columbus's Diario),
along with theoretical texts focusing on nature and identity. In
addition to the weekly readings, students will be responsible for
one class presentation and the preparation of a significant research
paper by semester's end.
5897 LIT 579 01 SpanAm Poetry: avant-garde/surr
W 12:45-3:15 Verani, Hugo
This seminar will study the principal tendencies of twentieth-century
Spanish American poetry, from the 1920s to the end of the century.
The emphasis will be on close readings of the texts along with recent
developments in critical theory. The poets to be considered are:
Vicente Huidobro, Jorge Luis Borges, Oliverio Girondo, César
Vallejo, Pablo Neruda, Octavio Paz, Nicanor Parra, and José
Emilio Pacheco. Course Grade will be based on the following criteria:
Term paper, 50%; Class participation, 30%; Oral presentation, 20%.
5899 LIT 591 01 The Wane in Spain
H 12:30-3 Nunez, Dayle
Despite the reputed cultural belatedness of the Iberian Peninsula
during the high Middle Ages, by the fourteenth century the Spanish
kingdoms had caught up with their European neighbors and entered
a period of general decline. The late Spanish Middle Ages is uniquely
defined by the ascendancy of the Tratámaras, a bastard line
that seizes the throne in 1369 when Enrique de Trastámara
murders his half brother, King Pedro I of Castile. The Trastámara
dynasty engineers the emergence of Spain as Europe's first modern
nation-state and world empire and the construction of an orthodox,
patriarchal "Spanish" and Catholic identity purified of
its ethnic, religious, and political others through propaganda,
conquest, conversion, colonization, expulsion, and inquisition.
The foundational union of Isabel (Castile) and Fernando (Aragon)
marked the culmination of the Trastámaran enterprise of political
legitimation, centralization, and expansion; the Catholic Monarchs
brought to closure seven hundred years of Reconquest, launched Europe's
invasion of a new world, laid the foundations for Spain's Golden
Age, and crafted the moral, political, and social recuperation of
Hispania.
The seminar will examine the cultural production of this complex
and fascinating age-the literary, historical, religious, and political
texts generated during the Trastámaran reign-in the context
of nation building, the formation of a persecuting society, and
the ultimately exclusionary ideology of Isabelline Spain. Texts
will include a course packet of selected primary and critical texts
plus: Juan Ruiz, Libro de buen amor; Don Juan Manuel, Libro del
conde Lucanor, Alfonso Martínez de Toledo, El arçipreste
de Talavera; sentimental romances (Grisel y Mirabella, Siervo libre
de amor, Cárcel de amor), and Celestina. Coursework includes
oral presentations and a final research paper.
5898 LIT 593 01 Transatlantic Lit & Hist/Trav
TH 3:30-4:45 Cachey, Theodor
This course approaches early modern Europe and its interactions
with the Americas through the lens of a theoretical and practical
preoccupation with the history and literature of travel. We'll begin
with a preliminary theoretical part focused by two primary texts
(Gilgamesh and Italo Calvino's Invisible Cities) together with selected
theoretical writings (E. Leed, C. Kaplan, D. McCannel, T. Todorov).
A "cartography and literature" section dedicated to cartographical
and literary sources documenting the transition from medieval to
modern ("Atlantic") travel will follow: medieval mappamundi,
"Dante's Ulysses," Boccaccio's "De canaria,"
Petrarch "viator," portolan charts, Ptolemy's Geografia.
The balance of the course will be dedicated to the study of a series
of early modern transatlantic "auctores," including Columbus,
Vespucci, Vaz de Caminha, Antonio Pigafetta, Luís de Camões,
Jean de Léry, Philip Sidney, the Inca Garcilaso de la Vega.
Discussion of primary texts will be complemented by an anthology
of critical readings to include selections from Tom Conley (The
Self-Made Map), Stephen Greenblatt (Marvelous Possessions), David
Harvey (Spaces of Hope) Frank Lestringant (Mapping the Renaissance
World), Tvetzan Todorov (The Conquest of the New World), Michel
de Certeau (The Writing of History), and Roland Greene (Unrequited
Conquests) among others. Participants in the seminar are invited
to develop a research paper based on sources in their primary "national"
literary field but with a significant "transatlantic"
comparative and/or theoretical component. For further information,
please contact the instructor at 631-5651 or at cachey.1@nd.edu.
CLASSICS
3796 CLLA 525 01 Latin Literature & Stylistics
TH 11:00-12:15 Krostenko, Brian
The aim of this class is an appreciation of the history of Latin
prose. The aim will be achieved in three ways. First, we will examine
samples of authors from Cato the Elder to Apuleius to isolate their
stylistic peculiarities and attempt to see shifts in style as responses
to varying social pressures in the Roman world. Second, we will
practice composing short pieces of Latin prose in imitation of some
of the peculiarities observed. Third, we will consider some general
problems in the history of Latin semantics, syntax, and style.
4772 CLLA 531 01 Latin Love Elegy
MWF 12:50-1:40 Mazurek, E. F.
This course will explore the literary genre of Latin love elegy
through close reading of the poetry of Tibullus, Propertius, and
Ovid. The major topics we will examine are the historical development
of the genre across the careers of these three poets, the relationship
of elegy to other literary genres, especially comedy, and elegy's
constructions of gender (men's and women's roles). Students' progress
in translating and analyzing the Latin texts will be gauged through
exams and interpretative essays.
5889 CLLA 576 01 Medieval Latin Survey
MWF 8:30-9:20 Sheerin, Dan
The aim of this course is to experience a broad spectrum of Medieval
Latin texts. Readings representative of a variety of genres (literary
and sub-literary), eras, and regions will be selected. Students
planning to enroll in this course should be completing Medieval
Latin I or they must secure the permission of the instructor. Those
with interests in particular text types should inform the instructor
well in advance so that he can try to accommodate their interests.
4770 CLGR 531 01 Advanced Greek: Philosophical
Poetry
TH 3:30-4:45 McLaren, Chris
This course will consist of a survey of Greek philosophical poetry,
along with a detailed examination of its place in the histories
of both literature and philosophy in the West. Beginning with instances
of proto-philosophical discourse in the poetry of Homer and Hesiod,
we will proceed to an in-depth consideration of the extant fragments
of the pre-Socratics Xenophanes, Parmenides, and Empedocles, and
conclude with the philosophical poetry of the Hellenistic and Imperial
periods, including, for example, Cleanthes' Hymn to Zeus, the Orphica,
and the Chaldean Oracles. We will analyze both the literary and
doctrinal elements of each work we read, and attempt to form an
overall impression of the relationships our authors establish between
these two aspects of the genre, especially in the context of what
Plato called the 'ancient quarrel' between philosophy and poetry.
5340 CLGR 500 01 Plato's "Phaedrus"
MW 4:30-5:45 O'Connor, David
This course will be an advanced seminar focused on reading Plato's
"Phaedrus" in Greek. Undergraduates must have completed
CLGR 325. Graduate students must have completed at least three semesters
of Greek. Class meetings will be about equally divided between translations
and interpretation.
FRENCH
1688 ROFR 500 01 French Graduate Reading
MWF 8:30-9:20 Martin, Patrick
This one semester, intensive study of French grammar and syntax
is intended for graduate students working in the Humanities or Sciences,
who are interested in acquiring intermediate level reading proficiency
in French. In addition to the translation exercises and practice
reading passages incorporated into Edward M. Stack's Reading French
in the Arts and Sciences (4th ed.), student participants will be
required to work with scholarly texts pertinent to their field of
research. Those students who successfully complete all class and
examination requirements will receive departmental certification
of their reading proficiency. No prior knowledge of French is assumed.
2036 ROFR 503F 01 Teaching Methods II
T 3:30-4:45 Dubreil, Sebastien
This course is only open to Graduate Teaching Assistants in French
in the Department of Romance Languages and Literatures. It will
continue to prepare Teaching Assistants to teach elementary French
courses. It will cover basic teaching techniques/methods used in
the ND French curriculum, course management, as well as test design
and evaluation techniques.
5880 ROFR 524 01 Visions & Miracles:
Religious Lit. in Medieval France
W 12:45-3:15 Boulton, Maureen
This course is designed to be an introduction to the religious literature
of medieval France. In addition to overtly religious works like
saints' lives and miracles of the Virgin, we will also read secular
works that deal with religious themes (La Chanson de Roland, the
Conte du Graal (Perceval) by Chrétien de Troyes, La Quête
du saint Graal). One of the themes of the course will be the overlap
between sacred and secular, and the appropriation of secular genres
by religious writers. Other readings will include French versions
of Bible stories, poetry of the troubadours and trouvères,
selections from the Miracles Nostre Dame of Gautier de Coinci and
from the Golden Legend, poems by Christine de Pizan, Guillaume de
Machaut, and François Villon. Reading knowledge of modern
French is essential. Depending on the will of the class, discussions
will be either in French or in English, but class presentations
and the research paper (ca. 18 pages) may be in either language.
IRISH
4056 CLIR 501 01 Beginning Irish I
T H 9:30-10:45 O'Conchubhair, Breen
An introduction to modern spoken and written Irish: basic principles
of grammar and sentence structure, as well as core vocabulary. Emphasis
is placed on the application of these principles in every-day situations.
Students learn how to conduct simple conversations: talking about
oneself and asking information of others; talking about family and
home; describing the weather and daily activities.
5871 CLIR 501 02 Beginning Irish I
TH 12:30-1:45 O'Conchubhair, Breen
An introduction to modern spoken and written Irish: basic principles
of grammar and sentence structure, as well as core vocabulary. Emphasis
is placed on the application of these principles in every-day situations.
Students learn how to conduct simple conversations: talking about
oneself and asking information of others; talking about family and
home; describing the weather and daily activities.
3939 CLIR 502 01 Beginning Irish II
T H 3:30-4:45 O'Conchubhair, Breen
Prerequisite: CLIR 501 or IRST 501
Second semester of instruction in the Irish Language. Continuation
of IRST 101/501. More emphasis will be placed on reading simple
texts in Irish. This course satisfies Irish Studies requirements.
5872 CLIR 502 02 Beginning Irish II
T H 11:00-12:15 McQuillan, Peter
Prerequisite: CLIR 501 or IRST 501
Second semester of instruction in the Irish Language. Continuation
of IRST 101/501. More emphasis will be placed on reading simple
texts in Irish. This course satisfies Irish Studies requirements.
4114 CLIR 503 01 Intermediate Irish
T H 9:30-10:45 McKibben, Sarah
Prerequisites: 102 and 102
A continuation of Irish 501 and 502 with increased emphasis on the
ability to read 20th century literary works in the original Irish.
PHILOSOPHY
5573 PHIL 505 01 Debate Between Plato &
Aristotle
TH 11:00-12:15 Gersh, Stephen
The course will study the history of the debate between the two
main ancient traditions of philosophy with special reference to
the theory that Platonism and Aristotelianism can, in some profound
manner, be reconciled. To the innocent modern observer, this idea
seems surprising. However, we must somehow account for the fact
that it seemed plausible to a substantial body of informed opinion
throughout later antiquity and the Middle Ages. In the first part
of the course, the emphasis will fall upon ancient philosophers
and especially Plotinus and the Platonic-Aristotelian commentators
of late antiquity (Porphyry, Proclus, Ammonius, Boethius). In the
second half of the semester, there will be a more rapid survey of
medieval approaches including "subterranean" Platonic-Aristotelianism,
Boethianism, the "Book of Causes," and Albertist readings
of Aristotle. Since (for the first part of the course at least)
translations are available, knowledge of Greek and/or Latin is useful
but not absolutely necessary. Requirement: one final paper of ca.
20 pp. Office hours: Tue, Thu 8.30-9.30.
5421 PHIL 548 01 Contemporary Continental
Philosophy
T 6:30-9:00pm Rush, Fred & Watson, Stephen
An examination of selected themes and problems in twentieth century
European philosophy. Reading from among: Husserl, Heidegger, Sartre,
Benjamin, and Adorno. Topic for S2003: self-presence, self-deception,
and false consciousness.
5430 PHIL 587 01 History of Philosophy of
Science to 1750
TH 2:00-3:15 Joy, Lynn
This seminar begins by examining four conceptions of science: those
of Plato, Aristotle, Epicurus, and Chrysippus. It then considers
how the natural philosophies developed by their ancient traditions
were transformed by medieval and modern thinkers, who significantly
revised the goals of previous scientific inquiry. Among the moderns,
we will focus on Descartes, Boyle, and Newton. Requirements: Course
requirements will include class presentations and two medium-length
papers.
5440 PHIL 659 01 Divine Providence
TH 9:30-10:45 Flint, Thomas
One of the central elements of orthodox Christian belief is the
affirmation of divine providence: God is seen not merely as the
creator of the world, but as its all-knowing controller and governor
as well. Given the existence of human freedom, however, questions
regarding the manner and degree of this governance naturally arise.
The overall purpose of this course will be to examine and evaluate
various conceptions of providence which stem from attempts to answer
these questions. More specifically, the course will focus on the
view of providence offered by the proponents of middle knowledge,
and the objections raised against this Molinist view by both its
traditional Thomist opponents and contemporary analytic philosophers,
especially advocates of "open theism". Possible employments
of the concept of middle knowledge to further our understanding
of the free will defense, foreknowledge, omnipotence, infallibility,
petitionary prayer, and the Incarnation will also be considered.
Texts: The two main texts for the course will be (i) Freddoso's
translation of (and introduction to) Part IV of Molina's Concordia
and (ii) Flint's Divine Providence: The Molinist Account. Others
whose works we will examine include William Hasker, Robert Adams,
and William Lane Craig.
Requirements: Two medium-sized papers (roughly 12 pages each) will
be required. At least one of these papers will be discussed in class.
5449 PHIL 680 01 Scientific Realism
TH 11:00-12:15 McMullin, Ernan
The controversy regarding realism and anti-realism has been one
of the two or three focal issues in the philosophy of science over
recent decades. After a brief look at the historical origins of
this controversy in early astronomy and in Newtonian mechanics,
we shall go on to study the criticisms, defenses, and explications
of scientific realism in the writings of van Fraassen, Putnam, Fine,
Hacking Laudan, Psillos, Kukla, and Ganson. We will rely mainly
on reproductions of selections from historical sources as well as
of recent articles.
Requirements: Term paper and take-home final.
5911 PHIL 641 01 Philosophy of Experience:
Husserl, Sartre, and Merleau-Ponty
TH 9:30-10:45 Gutting, Gary
Explicitly or implicitly, every modern philosophical enterprise
has had to guarantee a place for itself by showing that there is
something for it to know that escapes the grasp of empirical science.
For one influential line of development, from Descartes through
Husserl and the logical empiricists, experience is the source of
a certainty needed to provide foundations for scientific and everyday
knowledge. But experience has also attracted philosophers because
of its immediacy or concreteness, which they see as overcoming the
abstractions required for successful empirical science. The thought
is that the precision required for rigorously testing hypotheses
requires us to ignore certain aspects of our experience that are
not open to scientific (e.g., quantitative) formulation. The claim
(or hope), however, is that philosophy is capable of giving us an
epistemically adequate access to the experiential concreteness that
science must ignore.
The appeal to a philosophy of concrete experience has been especially
important in the French philosophy of the last one hundred years.
Despite their Cartesian origins, twentieth-century French philosophers
from Bergson through Merleau-Ponty, valued experience for its concreteness
rather than its certainty. This explains the ambivalent status of
Husserl for French existential phenomenologists; they admired his
project of describing the fullness of lived experience but were
uninterested in the use he proposed to make of these descriptions
to provide a rigorous foundation for all knowledge. The rejection
of the theme of certainty accords well with most recent philosophy,
both continental and analytic, which has rightly rejected foundationalist
efforts to ground knowledge in experiential certainties. But there
remain the central questions of how experience fits into a scientific
account of the world and whether philosophy has a special epistemic
role in virtue of its access to the realm of concrete experience.
In this course, I would begin with an examination of the place of
experience in Husserl's phenomenology, looking particularly at some
key sections of Ideas I and of the Crisis. Then I would move to
Husserl's reception among the French, focusing on central writings
of Sartre (Transcendence of the Ego and selected portions of Being
and Nothingness-e.g., the Preface) and of Merleau-Ponty (selections
from Phenomenology of Perception). I also hope to pay some attention
to later critiques of phenomenology and its conception of experience
(reading some bits of Heidegger, Derrida, and Foucault).
THEOLOGY
5622 THEO 523A 01 Reformation Theo.: Calvin's
New Testament Commentaries
TH 12:30-1:45 Zachman, Randall
Course Description: John Calvin dedicated his life to restoring
what he called "the genuine sense of Scripture" to the
Latin catholic church, in direct indebtedness to the efforts of
Laurenzo Valla, Desiderius Erasmus, and Faber Stpulensis before
him, as well as contemporaries such as Luther, Oecolampadius, Melanchthon,
Bucer, and Bullinger. This course will examine the ways Calvin interpreted
certain representative texts of the New Testament in order to see
if we might discern the distinctive ways in which he sought to arrive
at the genuine sense of Scripture, so that he might draw general
and fruitful doctrine for the church. We will begin with his first
commentary, on Romans, which serves as the pathway to the whole
of Scripture. We will then turn to First Corinthians, in order to
see how he deals with issues of ecclesiology and the sacraments.
The Epistle to the Hebrews will be examined next, as it serves as
the template by which Calvin interprets the whole of the Hebrew
Bible, as well as the basis of his polemic against Roman views of
the Mass and priesthood. We will end with the Gospel of John, which
shows Calvin's engagement with the patristic tradition of Biblical
commentaries, especially Irenaeus, Origen, and Augustine. The course
will be a combination of lecture and seminar discussion: I will
lecture on the assigned reading on Thursday, and we will have a
seminar discussion of the same reading on the following Tuesday.
Written evaluation will be based on seminar discussion and five
six-page papers on the different texts being read over the course
of the semester. This course assumes no prior knowledge of Calvin
or of the Reformation period.
1937 THEO 525 Topics in Early Christianity;
Prayer & Mysticism/Early Church
TH 3:30-4:45 Daley, Brian
Course Description: In this course, we will consider some of the
principal texts illustrating the growth of early Christian understanding
of personal prayer and union with God. Beginning with second-century
authors and reaching at least as far as Maximus Confessor (7th century),
we will consider how early Christian writers in both West and East
understood the Christian vocation to "pray always," and
interpreted the implications of prayer for everyday life and for
the Christian's hope of eternal life. Many Church Fathers developed
their views on prayer in terms of the most familiar of Christian
formulas, the Lord's Prayer, and wrote treatises interpreting that
brief text as the heart of Christian spirituality. Others offered
a version of what has come to be called "mystical" prayer,
in which the individual consciousness is so united with God as to
lose awareness of its own distinct individuality. Still others built
their theology of prayer on an interpretation of the Church's liturgical
and sacramental life, and presented the individual's quest for perfection
as a living-out of the Church's collective vocation as the Body
of Christ. In our attempt to see the main lines of development in
early Christian spiritual theology, we will read works by Clement
of Alexandria, Origen, Tertullian, Cyprian of Carthage, Gregory
of Nyssa, Evagrius of Pontus, Augustine, John Cassian, the Pseudo-Macarian
Homilies, the Pseudo-Dionysius, Diadochus of Photike, Maximus Confessor,
and others. We will consider the relationship of their treatment
of prayer and mysticism to their understanding and interpretation
of Scripture, their Trinitarian theology, and their view of the
status and the eschatological vocation of every person as called
to share in the life and being of God.
|