WPC  ia׈i)xiقy}YD}*a4J nbY.,@2Za,Wͱ$s0_CY&Ef]Ez৩oC/X03,g6?;z'YSh1ssC6 )s&ms=*{(;hFn*Z@nxBkḬem=cQP:A/ [cٌzYwt~*0TųagxZoPL7 b<3d_|aNsư_]i q\Rc-W£ިx=b"TTa_=8;UydYI˫mt"z IG"{[f~R E=cqSbqtM WAHhhGvmCw[& FEz\ %$bK>9I-ˈ|W#!UN %1 0(7UF_ 1 1u, 0 c E 1 1 ^  w@ 4` t  m 1 0N# *q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q B malloy2,,,,0(9 Z6Times New Roman RegularX($.@FAZ.Futura Md BT Medium(5hCEKQW]cioAutoList11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.3#37=CIQYag1.a.i.(1)(a)(i)1)a)(;3$2#  0  .3  0  (EhCEKQW]cioAutoList21.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.(UhCEKQW]cioAutoList31.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.G, _E`aEbcEdEefghEH, 3|xhU(ehCEKQW]cioAutoList41.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.(O$www.nd.edu/~kshrader d !  _HHXXTXXX  8DtXXdd8      P    BIOS543&@%XXTEthicsandScience        P     X (Spring2003)Professor:_Kristin_Ԁ_Shrader_Ԅ_Frechette_,0 X 0X$X$0$$0`$$ClassTime:Wednesday,46:30* z`$`$ Classroom:200Malloy    X      ` _Website_:4 nO  5  www.nd.edu/~kshrader65OI  7 Z#w  6 Office:211Malloy P     X      ` Officehours:T,W,Thafternoons,         P     X      `     SignupsheetondoorCoursegoals:torecognizetypicalethicalproblemslikelytoariseinconductingscientificresearch    torecognizesubtlewaysinferences,_models,and_Ԁmethodologicalvaluescanbiasscience    tounderstandthemanyconflictsofinterestthatfacescientistsdoingscientificresearch    toteachpeopletoavoidsuspectinferences,defaultrules,andsubjectivityinscience    touseclassicalethicaltechniquesforresolvingethicaldilemmasinscience    tounderstandnecessaryandsufficientconditionsfor_whistleblowing_Ԁinscience    toinvestigatealternativerulesfordealingwithscientificbehaviorunderuncertainty0  0$$0P $$  torethinkthevariouswaysthatunethicalsciencecancompromisevaluesofobjectivity,freeinformedconsent,dutiestothecommongood,rightstoknow,&responsibility P $P $ CourseRequirements:0 readingsforeveryclass;attendanceandproblemanalysisineveryclass;  4short,analyticpresentations/1pagepapers,every3weeks;101pagesynopsispapers;noexams.  $ $ BasisforCourseGrade:0 60percent:0X $ $4onepage,analytic,seminarpresentationsJX$X$      P  30percent:0 X 10onepagesynopsispresentations(X$X$      P  10percent:0 X inclassanalysisX$X$ 0  0$$0P $$0 P $P $Professorpresupposesclear,precise,journalreadyproseandperfectgrammar/spelling;usesoftwaretohelpensureboth.  $ $ CourseFormat:0 P Thefirsthalfofclasswillbeprofessorslectureonthetopicoftheday.Second $: % halfoftheclasswillbeseminarpresentationsbystudentsonthetopicoftheday. P $P $ CourseTexts:0 P severalNationalAcademyandAAASreportsonreserve;journalarticleson b(#) electronicreserve,mostlyfromScienceandNature;plus4books:C@)$*P $P $ C=7  77  77 P 7==0  0$$0P $$=E.Erwin,S._Gendin_,andL._Kleinman_,EthicalIssuesinScientificResearch,1994 *L&, (_EIS;R_;<)<;>8 P $P $ 888>R.L._Penslar_,ResearchEthics,1995?(RE)?;USNationalAcademyof +*'- Sciences,ResponsibleScience,1992@(RS)@;_Shrader_Ԅ_Frechette_,EthicsofScientific ,(. Research(paperback),1993BBA(ESR).A-(/P $P $ D t.)0      P     X D DD t.)0 Ї     P     X LectureOutlineAV ) xdEHkH!A l Week0  LectureTopics0 $$0 $ $0X$$0X$X$CaseStudy0`$$0`$`$  Assignment{$$ AV ) xdEHXH!A Y  L 5h(3L 3   325h  1  .3  0    importanceofethicsinscientificresearch;0$$scientificmisconduct0$$0$$Cole,11thPlague;3݌F$$ Ќ  0  overviewofmajorlogicalfallacies&0$$inUSlabs;National0$$ESR,ch.1;RE,ch.2$ t$$   5logicalcriteriaforanalysis:complete0  Academystudiesof R$$   ness,assumptions,consistency,0 X 0X$X$theselabs 0 $$ Ѐ0  consequences,coherence;  $$     howvaluesariseinscience0  0X$$0X$X$_hydrogeological_Ԁ_Scriven_,_Hempel_, $  @$  @$  @$  @$  @$  @$  z   models `     _chs_.12,_EISR_X $$ AV ) xdEHH!A d  2.0  Scientistscodesofprofessionalethics0$$_Milgram_Ԁresearch;0$$0$$ESR,ch.2;Q $$   Researchthatoughtnotbedone?0 X 0X$X$_Tuskegee_Ԁsyphilisstudy;  AAASethicsstudy/ $$   5rulestoavoidsuspectresearch0 X 0X$X$Lewisvs.Marcus:0$$0$$RS,_chs_.67$$   Plagiarismandattribution0  0X$$0X$X$CaseofPrincetonvs.Yale0$$_EISR_,ch.26y$$ AV ) xdEH4H!A 5 3.0  Objectivity;inferenceoptions;method0$$Doseresponsecurves0$$ESR,ch.3;_Mcmullin_"r$$   _ological_Ԁvaluejudgmentsinscience0  in_radiobiology_0$$0$$article;P$$ 0   $$ AV ) xdEHH!A   4.0  Problematicconceptsandhowthey0$$ Ecosystem, stability,&0$$McIntosh,Background$$   empirically_underdetermine_Ԁscience0  communityconceptsine0$$ofEcology,2_chs_.$$   _Deontological_,_contractarian_Ԁres.ethics0  _cology_; ecosystemhealth,e $$   Utilitarian,virtuetheoretic_res.ethics_0  EPA_EMAP_Ԁcase0$$0$$RE,ch.2!q"$$   _Deontological_ԀresearchethicsAV ) xdEH H!A  % 5.0  Theethicsofdatagathering&framing0$$Chernobyl,Hiroshima0$$_Schull_Ԁvolume,ch.?!'$$   Babbagescookingandtrimming0 X 0X$X$Nagasakidatabases;  _Dubrova_ԀinNature"($$   Speciousaccuracy    X   DOEframing0 ` 0`$`$0$$RE,ch.6d#)$$   Ethicalproblemsinaggregatingdata0  _CWD_Ԁanalysis    LosAlamos_EIS_B$*$$      P     X   LosAlamos_EIS_AV ) xdEH&H!A0  0$$&,"-$$ 6.0  Theethicsofcurvefittingandselecting0$$Islandbiogeography0$$0$$_Simberloff_Ԁ&Wilson'#/$$   nullhypotheses0 0 $ $0X$$0X$X$debate;0`$$0`$`$0$$RS,_chs_.23(#0$$      P     X   Claiborne,LA_EIS_0  0$$Claiborne_EIS_)$1$$ AV ) xdEH@+H!A A+&3      P     X  -:)7 AV ) xdqEHH!A       P     X   LectureOutline  AV ) xdEHXH!A Y Week0  LectureTopic0 $$0 $ $0X$$0X$X$CaseStudy0`$$0`$`$  Assignment h$$ AV ) xdEHEH!A F f7.0  Theethicsofconfirminghypotheses:0$$YuccaMountain    Q.Rev.ofBio.article3 $$   verification,validation,_benchmarking_;0  _hydrogeological_ J $$   problems_insystems_Ԁ&blackboxmodels  models0 ` 0`$`$0$$RE,_chs_.14,19  $$ AV ) xdEHN H!A O   L Eh((L 3   302Eh  8  .3  0    Lyingwithstatistics:heuristicbias,0X$$0X$X$Duponts_tudy_Ԁofformal0$$Mayo, Sociologicalvs30 1݌# s$$ Ќ    Lowpowerstudies   0 X 0X$X$_dehyde_Ԁcarcinogenicity0$$_Metascience_ԀViews : $$   Misconductinscience0  H0X$$HI0X$X$IJMITbiotechJKJ.JKLnologycaseLM0$$MNRE,_chs_.4,12;RS,ch.4Nx $$ AV ) xdEHH!A V  9.0  Conflictingduties,paternalism,and  Lowdosechemical_horme_Ԅ0$$ESR,ch.4* $$   _whistleblowing_Ԁinscience   X 0  sis study, JunkScience0$$_Calabrese_Ԁ&Baldwin0@#$$ $$ 0  0$$0P $$0 P $P $@* $ $0  0`$$0`$`$0$$RS,ch.5 $$ AV ) xd@EHH!A F 10.0  _Funders_controlofresearchpublication0$$TobaccostudyofHarvard0$$ESR,ch.5$$   Dutiestothecommongood X   RiskCenter;       P     X   UCA,SFs  Secrecyinscienceandcommongood  pharmaceuticalresearch0  _EISR_,_chs_.49o$$ AV ) xdEHH!A   @11.0  Researchanduncertainty0$$0X$$0X$X$NationalAcademystudy0$$NAS,Science&Judg"$$   Decisiontheoreticrulesforuncertainty;0  ofdefaultrulesinscience0$$_ment_,ESR,ch.6H#$$   TypesIandIIstatisticalerror0 X 0X$X$Ford_Mitre_Ԁstudy_$$$ AV ) xdEHH!A & 12.0  AdvocacyinScience:distinguishing0$$_Kangas_Ԁvs._Noss_Ԁon0$$0$$_Kangas_,_Noss_,inq($$   sciencefromscientistsopinions; X   tropicaldeforestation0  Bulletinofthe_ESA_;8)$$   confusingscientistsdifferentroles X   NASYuccastudy    ESR,ch.7 O*   militaryresearch0 0 $ $0X$$0X$X$Surrogatesinbiotech.0$$_EISR_,_chs_.2930!,$$      P     X   usedinchem.warfareAV ) xdEH#H!A #2/  L Uh(( L 3   3A2Uh  13  .3  0    Racialbiasandsexbiasinscience,0$$USresearchoncontracep0$$ESR,ch.8;_Wenneras_3AA݌$ 1$$ Ќ    especiallyclinicaltrials   X   _tion_,invitrofertilization,0  WoldinNature}% 2$$      P     X   &defs.ofmentalillness;0  D&!3$$      P     X   IQcontroversy0  0$$_EISR_,_chs_.2728 '["4$$ AV ) xd!EH(H!A (#6 14.0  Companyloyaltyandresearchdesign  FordPintodesign;    ESR,ch.9(#7$$   Conflictsofinterestbecauseof0 X 0X$X$0$$0`$$0`$`$0$$RE,ch.21m)$8$$     fundingsources   X   _Hydrolevel_Ԁdesign    DeGeorgearticle 4*%9 AV ) xdEH+H!A +'; @*15.0  Mandatedscience;0 $$ grayscience;0 $ $DOEresearch0$$0$$ESR,ch.10,'=$$   Specialconsiderationsinscienceforpub0  Confoundersintobacco]-(>$$   _lic_Ԁpolicy;dutiestodoprobonoscience0  case;diversitystabilityH$.t)?$$ ЇAV ) xdEHH!A  AV ) xdEHH!A   Class   0  SynopsisTopics:   $$  Week0  0$$Studentschoose10:0X$$SeminarTopics:StudentsChoose4XX$X$ AV ) xdEHH!A o   L eh(( L20  0$$ESR,_chs_.120 $$orch.5RE0X $ $Post1990casestudyonplagiarismCX$X$      P     X Post1990casestudyon_misattribution_30  0$$ESR,ch.3orch.12RE0X$$Post1990casestudyondeceptiveresearchH  X$X$      P     X Post1995casestudyonviolationsofinformedconsent $   _       P     X Post1990casestudyonprematurepublication40  0$$McIntosh0 $$0 $ $0X$$Post1990casestudyonsubjective,_nonempirical_Ԁconcepts d  0X$X$0$$0`$$0`$`$0$$0h$$0!h$h$0$!$!$ $$$$ 50  0$$_Dubrova_ԀinNature0$$0X$$Casestudyonthe_Lysenko_ԀepisodeorB X$X$      P     X Casestudyon_Kahneman_Ԁand_Tversky_60  0$$_Simberloff_ԀetalinEcology0X$$Post1990casestudyonproblematicnullhypothesesG X$X$     or_Oreskes_ԀetalinScience0 X ^ X$X$ 70  0$$_KSF_ԀinQuart.Rev.Biology0X$$Post1995casestudyonmisuseofcomputermodelsX$X$ 80  0$$Mayoon_Metascience_0X$$Post1995casestudyonmisleadingstatistics*zX$X$ 90  0$$ESR,ch.4orRS,ch.50X$$_0X$X$0$$_Post1990casestudyonscientific_whistleblowing_X$X$ 100  0$$ESR,ch.5`orRS,_chs_.23`0X$$a0X$X$0$$aPost1995casestudyonquestionableclinicaltrialsabroadFX$X$      P     X !indevelopingnations110  0$$ESR,ch.6gorRS,_chs_.67g0X$$h0X$X$0$$hPost1990casestudyonquestionabledefaultrulesX$X$ 120  0$$ESR,ch.70 $$0 $ $0X$$Post1995casestudyonquestionablescientificadvocacy)y!X$X$ 130  0$$ESR,ch.80 $$0 $ $0X$$Post1990casestudyongenderbiasinscienceor#X$X$      P     X Post1990casestudyonracialbiasinscience140  0$$ESR,ch.90 $$0 $ $0X$$Post1995casestudyonflawedresearchdesign \&X$X$ 150  0$$ESR,ch.10bor_EISR_,bcbchsbb.bb29bc0$$0X$$d0X$X$dPost1995casestudyonbiasedscienceusedforpolicye!(X$X$     ef_chs_.2930f