| |
Introduction
| It is a common experience that a problem difficult at night
is resolved in the morning after the committee of sleep has worked
on it." - John Steinbeck |
In today's Starbucks-driven colleges, as workaholics struggle to maintain
their drug of choice and caffeine-induced bursts of energy reign supreme,
the Western work ethic to "keep moving, don't stop for anything"
continues to pervade in students' minds. Virtually flying from class to
class in a race against his own deadline, a college student will sprint
through casual conversations and hurdle over rows of un-smelt roses for
the mere attainment of an alphabetical goal. One can only hope that an
A minus will satisfy his ever-growing need for top-ranking speed. Therefore,
as with all feverishly working students of any given college, only one
comment can be made to their increasingly rapid eye movements:
"Give it a rest, man."
With all the hard work and dedication involved in living such a fast-paced
college-life, students develop a tendency to ignore their personal health
in order to succeed in the world around them. One of the most prevalent
sacrifices made by college students rests in the basic human need to reenergize,
in which both body and mind participate in an ancient ritual of replenishment
- the act of sleep. Oddly enough, the subject of sleep deprivation rarely
raises such heated debates or concerns as "binge drinking in anorexic
athletes," for example, and consequently receives less attention.
This apathy, however, introduces the purpose of my proposal to eliminate
or, at least, lessen the detrimental effects that sleep deprivation might
have on students' health. In order to do so, colleges must raise awareness
and concern around the subject of sleep and execute this in a manner that
every sleep-deficient student has the opportunity to participate and to
help themselves. Thus, to facilitate a more health-oriented, successful
college experience and to counteract the negative effects of poor sleeping
habits on each student, I believe that college universities must implement
a relaxation training program into their educational system.
Causes of Sleep Deprivation
First and foremost, before any steps are taken in the application of an
educationally-based relief system, we as members of a college family must
understand that sleep deprivation among college students stems from a
number of school-related factors. The college academic workload's correlation
between the outcomes of learning and a student's environment were observed
in a recent study where researchers noted "students' perceptions
of workload... link higher workloads to generally poorer learning outcomes
and satisfaction with the learning environment" (Simons 37). Not
surprisingly, the element causing the most anxiety dwells in heavy academic
workloads, as college students' competitive environments push them to
lose the most sleep.
Moreover, the increased amount of work in colleges today has done little
to reduce the amount of time each employed student gives to their job.
According to an article entitled "The Impact of Sleep on Learning
and Behavior in Adolescents," the amount of sleep that adolescents
obtain is largely determined by the increased academic workload coupled
with employment positions needed to "supplement family income, increase
independence, improve self-confidence, and develop interpersonal skills,"
all of which promote a healthier mode of thinking (Mitru 710). The consequences
of all the positive increases, on the other hand, include having to work
longer hours at work, which accordingly hinder opportunities for a sufficient
amount sleep. Motivated by a paycheck and the desire to keep up with their
classes, these soldiers of schoolwork ultimately forfeit a healthy amount
of sleep with little to no regret. After all, the end justifies the means,
right? Popular opinion would say that ajob well done validates students'
disregard for sleep, but hopefully further examination of sleep deprivation's
effects will deter this mentality.
The Need for a Program
To determine the absolute necessity of a relaxation training program,
college universities should consider a primary analysis of students' sleeping
habits. In order to ascertain a general idea of student's regular sleeping
practices, a survey was conducted of over 100 Notre Dame students (less
than 10% of the Notre Dame student body). Approximately 70% reported receiving
only five to six hours of sleep on the weekdays, 28% receiving seven to
eight, and only 2% receiving the healthy nine hours for teenagers. Because
the majority of students receive significantly less than the healthy sleeping
regimen, these first signs of sleep deprivation should signal the Notre
Dame Administration to develop a form of action. Furthermore, the same
survey sheds much light on the consequences of these poor sleeping habits.
A shocking amount of students, more than two-thirds, reported to have
missed either a class or a test this semester due to issues surrounding
sleep. From these statistics, Notre Dame seemingly contradicts its original
purpose of having students reach their fullest intellectual potential
in one way: creating an environment conducive for a problem that actually
inhibits learning. Subsequently, if Notre Dame may serve as a microcosm
for all universities, perhaps these first steps in revealing an exceedingly
accepted problem will push the call for some sort of action in all educational
systems.
Relaxation Program as Education
In order to bring about the most successful program for students, the
execution of such a relaxation course must primarily focus on raising
sleep-deprivation awareness, including knowledge surrounding causes and
effects of the widespread problem. To determine the present amount of
awareness among students today, a survey conducted of more than 900 students
on the subject of proper sleep hygiene reported the average correct response
rate was approximately 50% (qtd. in Relationship of Sleep 33). Not surprisingly,
these numbers specifically indicate a direct link between sleep hygiene
awareness and the poor sleeping habits so rampant among college students.
Their ignorance of the subject lends credence to the popular argument
that irresponsible sleeping habits are not the students' fault; rather,
many students are merely unaware of sleep deprivation's damaging effects.
For example, a common misconception held by many university students states
that "I can just catch up on the weekends" or "A little
nap will make it all better," when in reality these practices actually
worsen a person's sleep intake. Scientists have observed these destructive
habits in three independent studies, concluding that "large variations
in sleep schedules produce almost the same difficulties as receiving less
than a normal amount of sleep," (qtd. in Applying Sleep Research
413). In that case, while allowing the instant gratification of closingone's
tired eyes for an hour or so, taking naps only gives the illusion of a
more restful day and night.
Along with the ill-conceived notion of "catch up" on the weekends
remains another misconception regarding relaxation: unwinding through
alcohol. Many people, including students, mistakenly believe that drinking
promotes sleep when, in fact, it reduces sleep quality by "suppress[ing]
REM sleep," an acronym for the integral sleeping stage of Rapid Eye
Movement (qtd. in Applying Sleep Research 413). So while an overly-worked
college student may feel a bit sleepy after a shot or two, repeated "nocturnal
awakenings" that evening can interrupt the natural state of REM resulting
in a lower quality of sleep and, therefore, cause a less restful night.
Still, students will disregard alcohol's harmful effects on their REM's,
acknowledging that they sometimes sleep even longer after drinking; however,
a relaxation program possesses the potential of dispelling this idea through
stressing the importance of quality over quantity. By doing so, the program
raises awareness through flipping common mistakes around and separating
the truth from the myths.
Moreover, considering various pieces of information, in particular,
could stimulate a barrage of internal questions among students such as:
"Do I display these sleeping habits? What is my sleeping schedule?
What can I do to stop it?" Thus, by disclosing eye-opening situations
to which every apt pupil may relate, students will approach the program
with raised awareness and concern, paving the way for an educationally-based
program.
Relaxation Program as Sleep Stimulus
Nevertheless, imparting information on sleep in an organized approach
makes up only part of the program. The next step in preparing a successful
system involves the creation of actual sleep promoting behaviors, which
will consist of relaxation techniques and skills that students may take
with them into the coming years of college. New methods of relaxation
such as "sustaining passive simple focus" as suggested by Jonathan
Smith, editor of Advances in ABC Relaxation Training: Applications and
Inventory, introduce the idea of "centering" into a student's
constantly outward range of thinking (5). Consider this analogy: An architecture
major is forever consumed with the arches above a balcony, yet remains
completely oblivious to the curvature of each bag beneath her eyes. A
relaxation program, however, works to improve upon such lack of self-awareness
on one's health. Students learn the value of slowing down, focusing inward,
and later experience what Smith terms a "cycle of renewal,"
in which a person awakens refreshed and renewed (Smith 6). Thus, through
focusing inward and away from the "discursive activities" of
school life, such methods of relaxation like centering will eliminate
the yearning for constant movement (Smith 5). As a result of slowing down,
the program further encourages the worth of sleep and fulfills one element
of the training.
Overall, a relaxation program with an informal atmosphere will not only
add to its appeal, but support the various needs of each student in the
group. A study cited within Advances in ABC Relaxation stresses the importance
of this casualness when observing that "casual relaxation activities
such as meditation, talking, listening to music and chatting... are most
rewarding and effective" (Smith 190). In terms of promoting sleep,
the study notes, "Interestingly, these activities are not particularly
effective for evoking relaxation states of mind other than sleepiness,"
the goal of the program itself (Smith 192). Obviously, casual activities
such as chatting do not solely produce a successfiil sleep and relaxation
program. However, in encouraging a familiar environment that promotes
relaxing behaviors, then, the program might succeed in its objective to
promote sleep.
Additional Reasons for a Relaxation Program
A relaxation training problem offers solutions not only for problems directly
posed by sleep deprivation, but irnproves the general performance of any
student with a school-related problem. In particular, many students possess
a high amount of anxiety surrounding exams and exhibit a kind of behavior
called "test anxiety," a special case of a general anxiety related
to fear of failure (S app 79). As a result of this constant concern about
their performance, ensuing loss of sleep can wreak similar effects as
with a student who simply loses sleep from late-night parties. In a multi-component
treatment approach conducted by one researcher in the journal entitled
Education and Treatment of Children, relaxation techniques and certain
cognitive-behavioral interventions were used to treat a nineteen year
old female with test anxiety. She eventually learned the importance of
PMR, or progressive muscular relaxation, to be applied quickly in stressful
situations like test-taking. As a result of applying these relaxation
skills and knowledge during stressful times, trait anxiety level decreased
and OPA increased substantially (Kennedy 2). In brief, the continued application
of an organized relaxation procedure succeeded in all forms. Much like
the female in this study, most students who feel the perpetual burden
of anxiety could benefit from the relaxation skills offered in a program,
both alleviating certain forms of apprehension and increasing the quality
of a college experience.
Implementation
Under my plan, I propose that Notre Dame serve as an example for all universities
by offering an optional 1-hour course every week within the current curriculum
to raise awareness about sleep deprivation. The program would serve as
a second rotation of the already required Contemporary Topics course.
Therefore, the argument that "I have no time" is refuted because
students would have had to take a second rotation anyway. Forcing students
to take another class besides the commonly labeled time-consuming PE requirements
and "Useless" Contemporary Topics might even appear silly. For
example, out of the 100 students that answered "yes" to attending
such a program, approximately 90% agreed that it should not be mandatory.
One student from Dillon Hall even went so far as to write within the margins,
"Making people do things is bad. People are not dogs." Indeed,
hounding educated adults to complete another credit only intensifies their
overloaded academic schedules, constraining the available free time they
possess and, thus, contradicting its original purpose to improve relaxation
and sleeping habits. Theoretically, by likening itself to another required
course for first-year students, the program might actually cause some
students to focus merely on getting through the class rather than growing
from it. On the other hand, if students are given the opportunity to participate
in a newly formed "nap class" as a second part of their required
PE course, the relaxing connotations of a required health class will raise
interest and, therefore, excitement to learn.
As for the audience that the program needs to attract, each session
would be open to all students wishing to escape the high-speed movements
from day to day, providing a calming center conducive for learning and
relaxing. Franklin C. Brown, head researcher of Applying Sleep Research
to University Students, proposes the basic ingredients for a student sleep
education program in that "the first step is providing students with
a brief literature summary of the impact that sleep difficulties have
on their lives, e.g. lower grades, concentration difficulties, and irritable
mood" (412). As outlined before, these sessions will primarily focus
on eliminating misconceptions about sleep and providing information on
the consequences of not receiving enough. In addition, sleep hygiene instructions
will provide the students with some basic tips to sleeping well and how
to avoid sleep deterrents such as caffeine, alcohol, unnecessary naps,
etc. Perhaps a planned activity at each meeting will provide for specific
needs, for example by having each student create a working schedule of
when to sleep, when to exercise, etc. This method would not only improve
the organization of the program, but also assist students in ridding the
aforementioned problem of variations within sleeping schedules. As recently
stated, the purpose of this first half of the session may hopefully eliminate
the ignorance surrounding sleep deprivation expressed in many students.
To improve upon concentration and physical health, the second part of
the weekly program will center on physical relaxation techniques and therapy.
Successful therapy practices are documented in a study entitled "Effectiveness
of Cognitive/Relaxation Therapy...," in which test subjects were
given 30 minutes of deep relaxation muscle therapy, breathing techniques,
and were encouraged to eliminate anxiety-inducing mentalities such as
feelings of failure (Dendato 132). The test proved successful in eradicating
feelings of anxiety, which in turn may improve the concentration skills
of students that repeat these methods. By imitating these procedures,
students can teach themselves how to relax and, therefore, sleep better
at night.
Finally, the program offered should maintain a similar extracurricular
counterpart, which will be relatively free of charge. To those students
and faculty not familiar with PE rotations, certain courses that are offered,
such as fencing, possess a corresponding club in which students with newfound
interest in the subject may participate. In the case that some students
leave the required relaxation training program wanting more, they are
given the chance to enjoy its benefits during their own time.
In addition, the coexisting club, though probably requiring dues like
any other student run organization, will remain free because a program
which boasts "Learn how to sleep successfully for 20 dollars"
might obviously detract from its popularity. Instead, the university should
fund the program and its trainers. If money poses a large obstacle in
its establishment, perhaps the university could "hire" upperclassmen
to instruct incoming freshman; those instructors, in turn, would receive
benefits such as credit hours if their major is Education, for example.
Through attracting students to a program with "free" as a kind
of bait, the goal of raising awareness about sleep deprivation has already
been accomplished.
Conclusion
I was slowly made aware of the problem of sleep deprivation after settling
into a lecture class of 150 students, observing the endless struggles
to find the most comfortable position into which the student body could
slowly sink unnoticed by the professor. Now, perhaps by introducing a
program that furthers this awareness to others in my "position,"
Notre Dame and all universities may benefit from a program that helps
alleviate the constant drag of sleepless nights and caffeine-driven days.
Despite the 75% of Notre Dame students surveyed that responded "No"
to attending such a proposed program (most of whom did not even meet the
healthy sleep requirements), perhaps these kind of results only further
the argument that we need to raise more awareness concerning sleep deprivation.
Because of this speculation, I feel that such an untested program requires
more research from both universities and students alike. Together with
the support and eagerness of the sleepy students, themselves, such a program
has the possibility of eliminating sleep deprivation. For, in a crude
alteration of Steinbeck's words, problems of sleep are solved only with
the conjoined efforts of a committee sharing them.
Sleep Deprivation Survey
| General Questions |
| 1) Male or female? |
| 2) What year are you? |
| 3) Where are you from? |
| 4) What is your major? |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
| Please answer the questions from the following choices: |
Answer |
% |
Answer |
% |
Answer |
% |
| 5) On average, how many hours
of sleep do you receive on a weekday? |
1-2 hours |
0% |
3-4 hours |
3% |
5-6 hours |
62% |
| 7-8 hours |
34% |
9 or more |
2% |
|
|
| 6) On average, how many hours
of sleep do you receive on weekends? |
1-2 hours |
0% |
3-4 hours |
3% |
5-6 hours |
15% |
| 7-8 hours |
46% |
9 or more |
36% |
|
|
| 7) Has lack of sleep ever kept
you from class or a test? If so, how often? |
Never |
33% |
once or twice this semester |
36% |
once or twice a month |
21% |
once or twice a week |
10% |
|
|
|
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
| Other:
|
| 8) What year (or time during the year) do you receive
the least amount of sleep?
|
| 9) On a scale of one to twn, how would you rate yur
normal sleeping habits?
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
| Please answer the questions with one of the following
choices: |
Answer |
% |
Answer |
% |
Answer |
% |
| 10) If an hour long relaxation program offering different
meditation techniques and relaxation skills was implemented at Notre
Dame, would you consider attending? |
Yes |
24% |
No |
43% |
Maybe |
33% |
| 11) Would you want such a program to be a mandatory
credit for students at Notre Dame? |
Yes |
7% |
No |
75% |
Not Sure |
18% |
| 12) Do you feel such a program would help your sleeping
habits at all? |
Yes |
15% |
No |
61% |
Maybe |
24% |
| 13) Would it affect your academic performance at all? |
Yes |
11% |
No |
33% |
Not Sure |
56% |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
Notes:
91% of students saying yes to question #10, said no to being mandatory
|
|
|