Themes and Comments from the Libraries’ Brainstorming Sessions

 

The following outline identifies broad themes that were extracted from brainstorming sessions conducted by the Strategic Planning Steering Committee in late June/early July.  For ease of reading, they are organized by the theme with the fewest comments to the theme with the most comments.  (Compiled by Parker Ladwig.)

 

A.  Improve communication with the University and within the Libraries

1.       Improve communication between departments

2.       Better communication between Hesburgh and branches and units

3.       Need better interdepartmental communication

4.       Need better interlibrary communication

5.       Need better communication with students and public and faculty--more imaginative--Web, newsletters, etc.

6.       Better communication out to the University faculty, rest of the University

7.       More communication among depts. about changes--often find out after

8.       Do not know about procedures that have changed

9.       Ensure that all library areas receive the same communications/information

10.   Find more ways to have direct communication rather than all-electronic communication

11.   Figure out ways to increase communication channels between library and our primary clientele

12.   Make staff more aware of internal communication by the Director and ADs, e.g., library-wide information session--staff provide personal goals but are not aware of other depts./units goals

13.   Responses from LibQual, focus groups, etc. show that many misperceptions exist among faculty regarding ease of access, availability of electronic resources, ILL services, etc. Feedback from Faculty Workshops conducted this summer was generally positive and indicated a need to continue this strategy.

14.   Better communication, especially from the top down, to foster trust

15.   Explore communication with users

 

B.  Enhance the collections

1.       Do not neglect books!

2.       Seek cooperative collection sharing with other universities based on their strengths and our strengths--virtual or regional

3.       Maintain and continue to build our print collections

4.       Improve communication with the professors of departments across campus to bring in collections that more meet the needs of the students

5.       Develop a balanced, comprehensive plan that includes collecting, acquiring, cataloging, and preserving for premiere programs in partnership with the corresponding department/institute/college/unit

6.       Collections need to keep up with the changing research

7.       ND should contribute more than Special Collections to online collection--digitize--free on the Web

8.       Take more advantage of physical historical or rare books--maybe an actual credit course; have available for future generations

9.       Look at gifts program--"books"

10.   More attention to streamlining print vs. digital

11.   Stacks need to be weeded, very old books

12.   Thorough review and weeding of the collection; for example, in areas like technology where it looks like much was moved from Engineering to HESB GEN in the past without collection development or bibliographic review

13.   Provision of a formal and funded collection of unabridged audio books (books on tape, CD) in a wide range of subjects and literatures, including foreign language fiction and non-fiction. These are not just for entertainment or leisure use, they are an important way to acquire information conveniently

14.   Focus collections in collaboration with other campus units that demonstrate the use and need for the library

15.   Provide top resources on "supporting the Catholic mission":  manuscripts, antiquarian books, Catholic resources, social justice, education, etc.

16.   Think about quality of collections rather than quantity--spend money wisely; focus on collections we do have

17.   Identify core collections and preserve them

18.   Stop buying useless books

19.   Develop plan to add electronic resources

20.   Develop methods and consortial arrangements with which to cut, preserve, make good decisions regarding serials

 

C.  Increase funding

1.       Major, major endowment for renovation

2.       Framework allowing budget to be used as planning tool

3.       Do not cut the budget

4.       Seek endowment funding for new library positions

5.       Increase budget for books, serials, and databases

6.       Need more funding for electronic resources

7.       Be able to purchase more serials materials, staff, serials training for staff

8.       Committee that ACTIVELY pursues fund raising for just library

9.       See us get several million dollars of unrestricted endowments

10.   Library should encourage College of Arts and Letters to capitalize its faculty in same way Engineering and Science colleges do--administration puts up funding for laboratories for new hires--administration should do this across the board--part of hiring package should include capital for library

11.   Better budgeting process (proactive vs. reactive, e.g., building renovation)

12.   Make priorities with funding

13.   Balance acquisitions funding with space needs--tell faculty they can't buy more books unless we have the space

14.   More funding, but how will it be raised?

15.   Increase collections budgets equitably based on dept. size, for example

16.   Increase funding so that requests can be accommodated, e.g., for carpeting

17.   Provide clearer financial picture of libraries, what was budgeted, what was spent

18.   Make plan to spend money for depts.

19.   Move funds to opportunities

20.   Substantially increase funding for preservation of paper materials

21.   Increase funding for re-formatting--such as photoduplication

22.   More projects driven by donations--is this a good idea?

23.   Funding for core materials, i.e., book, Catholic baseline University budgets

 

D.  Provide more bibliographic instruction/information literacy programs

1.       Educate undergraduates about library resources and services

2.       Educate foreign students

3.       Require faculty to make library assignments

4.       Instruction for graduate students (e.g., EndNote), dissertation support

5.       Basic instruction for graduate students on how to use catalog, maybe small groups

6.       Offer instruction on digital resources and tools for staff and faculty in cooperation with OIT, e.g., the CEP program

7.       Develop our pedagogical role both external and internal to the library

8.       Bibliographic instruction for large research areas

9.       More formal credit courses on finding information anywhere

10.   Offer more specialized/reference collection development, instruction focused on academic departments, classroom teaching, help work on projects

11.   Become leaders in teaching information literacy

1.       High school students should be encouraged to come to the library for research--with some instruction

12.   Teaching and learning center library; students learn to make Web pages and use multimedia in projects

13.   Do more with multimedia, e.g., video, Photoshop, to be used in class/teaching

14.   Use library materials in multimedia environment and get Art/Marketing Depts. involved

15.   Add more instructional support staff

16.   Coordinator of instruction to be dept. head level position; create an Instruction Dept.

17.   Provide "who to contact" information at branches

18.   More instruction librarians

19.   Provide more instructional sessions to staff about how to use our resources

20.   Add library research component to majors

21.   Increase resources available to continue expansion of Library Instruction Program

22.   Tremendous growth in Freshman Instruction sessions needs to be sustained to maintain credibility with First Year Composition Department.

23.   There is need to focus on other levels; e.g.,first year graduate students, sophomore CORE students, subject specialties, but current classroom and instructor availability limit growth.

24.   More resources (physical, human) dedicated to library instruction

25.   Compulsory bibliographic instruction

 

E.  Ask the University to do more for the Libraries

1.       Need campus copyright expert, including for faculty

2.       Gain control of whole Hesburgh Library building

3.       Take stand on parking lot or provide shuttle

4.       Seek cooperative funding between University centers and the library to provide for new areas of research

5.       Form a student advisory committee for libraries

6.       More classroom support at all levels, not just freshman

7.       Inform library staff of University's vision of the library's future

8.       Ask University what the plans are for the libraries

9.       Improved parking--IN FRONT

10.   Library should be main focus of University vs. sports

11.   Library should be center of any learning institution

12.   See University Libraries be able to better communicate with administration that the library is a capital investment rather than a capital expense

13.   University faculty should know us, and we should know them

14.   Working more closely with Kaneb or OIT about Hesburgh computer cluster

15.   Get University administration to know library employees

16.   Library is most important for students, but constantly underfunded (does not attract students); should be the center of the University because of its knowledge, resources, etc.

17.   Centralized person to handle copyright problems

18.   Hire paralegal to help with copyright issues

19.   Copyright consultant for the campus, not just the library

20.   Encourage faculty not to put things off to the last minute for reserves

21.   Better communication with registrar's office to open rooms

22.   More public campus phones

23.   University should build relationship with outside community, high school students

24.   University Libraries reclaim 14th Floor

25.   Allow students to visit 14th Floor

26.   ND Security should let library security know of situations like looking for someone in the building, etc.

27.   Would like University administration to rank library higher in priority

28.   On game days, stagger bus drop-off in front of the library

29.   More collaboration with Kaneb, OIT, Office of Institutional Research

30.   Integrate Law Library catalog with University Libraries

31.   Coordinate with campus tour groups so that accurate information is conveyed to tourists

32.   Raise our ranking among research libraries

33.   Budgetary relationship with University administration--assure maintenance of existing serials collection

34.   Better management of road construction on Juniper

35.   More recognition of library renovation by University administration

36.   Reserve parking for staff and faculty

37.   Improve parking on football Saturdays

 

F.  Improve efforts to market the Libraries’ services and collections

1.       Convey importance of library to Notre Dame community

2.       Libraries more integrated into campus life, less of a warehouse

3.       Attract campus visitors to library

4.       Increase awareness of Special Collections

5.       Let public and users know who and what we are, what we offer, advertise on football weekends, sell name plates, alumni weekends, some kind of advertising package

6.       Subliminal messages "use the library," "the library is good"

7.       Need to get patrons in the doors

8.       Increase use of physical library

9.       Better donor recognition

10.   Promotional/instructional packet during registration/beginning of semester (e.g., like Papa John's); tour of library on CD-ROM, Web (but every floor's the same); send it to freshman before they get here; reference librarians greet them, like Wal-Mart or casino

11.   Attract new donors through recognition of current donors

12.   Improve libraries' image via committees

13.   Bring students back to library

14.   Connecting more with user community

15.   Articulate, develop, implement program to bring people back to the library (overemphasis on desktop delivery)

16.   More instruction/marketing/outreach for electronic resources to teaching faculty

17.   Other depts. on campus know of the library, but don't know the people running it

18.   Get parents to look at library before they let their children come to ND

19.   Look for big donors

20.   Define what our services are and then market them--"we're afraid that we won't be able to keep up"; give the Business School marketing students one of these projects

21.   Provide Fall open house for new faculty each year

22.   Provide new faculty tours every year

23.   Strengthen relationships between library faculty and depts. on campus

24.   Increase public relations with University

25.   Create one glossy brochure for all libraries

26.   Identify ways to emphasize Catholic nature of libraries

27.   Be more prominent on campus as a whole--not just to University administration

28.   Better marketing of resources

29.   More advertisement of library services and resources

30.   Active role on campus; active partner with OIT; perhaps other university libraries for computer networking and facilities

31.   Ongoing library awareness program to improve our marketing outside the library

32.   Look at the library in a competitive/commercial environment, think of ourselves in business terms, find ways to compete with these services

33.   Spearhead/take leadership role in collaborative efforts with the campus as a whole--library can benefit every dept. on campus

34.   Do more events to market/attract folks outside the library--series of events on popular topics, could be preservation of books, book making/binding, answer questions, have hands-on materials

35.   Discover and implement program for establishing trust between ourselves and our primary clientele

36.   Tables, chairs, etc. in library courtyard to encourage people to come in

37.   Provide a place to look at popular, less-expensive periodicals while enjoying your coffee

38.   Have book signings, speakers, etc.

39.   Publicize distinguished collections using Web page

40.   Advertise preservation awareness to students

41.   Bring Your Child to the Library day

 

G.  Improve access to the Libraries’ resources

1.       More needs assessment, usability testing

2.       Systems should be more responsive to cataloging needs, higher in priorities

3.       Streamline electronic resources and access to it

4.       Conduct usability studies--review existing library material documentation for ease of use for patrons

5.       Build science and technology library, human and material resources in one library--eliminate never-ending shift of collections to Hesburgh from branches

6.       Consolidate e-resources gateway and virtual reference, and reorganize the new page

7.       Table of contents in Aleph; Integrate Aleph and Gateway

8.       More focus on the Gateway, more user friendly, sometimes confusing

9.       Mirror site for online content

10.   Creating or purchasing one search engine for all resources

11.   Aleph GUI via the Web

12.   All libraries wireless, platform independent

13.   Centrally located science or history of science library for journals, etc.; older material/storage and public service and current service

14.   Put microfilm to computer [sic]

15.   Selected resources available to reprint, put in digital form

16.   Digital reformatting

17.   Master database of all materials (reserve), drawings, articles, symposium, accessible to professors--could be part of Aleph

18.   Catalog all rare books

19.   Put into practice principles of user-centered design in everything we do

20.   Keep the system more user friendly:  catalog

21.   Better equipment in microtext

22.   System brought up to date to download records for other vendors via EDI

23.   Catalog needs enhancing particularly records--some subjects are inaccessible; *microfilm--better analytics in collections

24.   Learn how to make information on Internet available to students in an easy-to-use format

25.   New courses of study should be categorized and catalogued--books be made available to the public--non-Roman [sic]

26.   Catalog:  serials with online access, URL should be imbedded in the bibliographic record

27.   Keep catalog system updated and current

28.   Attack back-log in cataloging (hire someone?/more assistance)

29.   Work on back-log for electronic resources--(reciprocal notes) impacted by physical back-log

30.   Rare Book room should be open on weekends

31.   Encourage electronic providers to have stable access--here today, gone tomorrow, not linked to ultimate resources

32.   A/V collection digitized so patrons can access it via the Internet

33.   More ports throughout the library for patron and staff to connect to the Internet (more wireless)

34.   All access services should be available via Aleph

35.   Archive/catalog microformat collection

36.   Desensitize books from other branch libraries--problem for security

37.   Make swipe cards available for late hours access

38.   Digitize microformats

39.   Implement wireless in all libraries

40.   Improve Internet service

41.   Make all public services areas hours uniform

42.   Expand delivery of materials to the desktop

43.   Adopt "MyLibrary" concept for Gateway

44.   24 hour home delivery of library materials on campus

45.   Make Reference area computers faster

46.   Provide more computers

47.   Provide laptop with Aleph client so the holdings work in stacks is easier

48.   Continue to up-grade quality control in technical service processes and products so that standard procedures are clearly understood and followed uniformly

49.   Enhance usability of digital library services

50.   Enhance access to ND's and other institutions' collections and services (e.g., document delivery/desktop delivery, page service to find books, self-initiated ILL, librarians who have offices throughout campus)

51.   Improve modes of resource discovery

52.   Set up usability lab to make testing/studies easier

53.   Catalog and make accessible collections in backlog (including microfilm) before purchasing more

  1. More descriptive records of microtext collections

55.   Purchase collections if and only if they can be accessible in a short time

  1. Foster more collaborative lending agreement with other libraries
  2. Aleph should be more responsive, i.e., customization for ND
  3. Better organization of electronic materials
  4. Develop expertise for greater delivery and preservation of digital materials
  5. Easier for patrons to find all materials--correctly link things together
  6. Open 24 hours a day when school is in session
  7. Rethink current directory for serials
  8. Expand Web presence for off site access to library resources
  9. Re-examine service hours in all areas--and staffing
  10. Do not open current periodicals center for checkout

 

H.  Provide additional services to patrons

1.       Complement commercial services such as Google, Barnes and Noble

2.       Self-checkout

3.       Web access for patrons to renew, etc., their books

4.       Implement document delivery for all faculty and students of books

5.       Improve communication between ILL and branches and patrons

6.       Allow patrons to make direct requests through ILL

7.       Allow public to use and check out materials

8.       Invest in or explore international document delivery beyond traditional ILL to assist research

9.       Self-renewal of checked-out material

10.   Self-ILL/bypass library ILL

11.   Improve and quicken ILL services with tracking of status

12.   Information friendly, always open to staff and patrons--always ready to answer questions--service oriented

13.   Extend concept of chat reference

14.   Change machine that has more than just quarters

15.   Self-checkout of books/materials

16.   Improve quality of printing images

17.   Online reserves--the photocopied materials online, can be reused, easily accessible

18.   Need:  have to be able to deliver physical material to user faster--particularly ILL and acquisitions

19.   Print on demand

20.   Ask students what we are lacking, what they would like, library should be center of University

21.   Survey students

22.   Literature searches for faculty/staff

23.   Making clients/patrons/users more efficient

24.   Open restrooms on main floor, especially for football weekends

25.   More services that allow patrons to do things for themselves

26.   More seamless time between time something is wanted, and it is delivered

27.   Help students know about subject librarian; provides relationship to help students; night reference staff better trained for this

28.   Service should be available for public service needs--staff--patron needs

29.   More patron-empowerment, e.g., self-checkout, e-mail notices going out, automated reserve

30.   Special Collections areas should have more of a public service attitude

31.   Self-checkout/empowerment for patrons (e.g., University of Chicago--lights turn off when areas is not in use)

32.   Increase number of computers for staff and patrons

33.   Self-checkout/patron empowerment

34.   Library staff need identification tags--no names, but identity as staff

35.   Staff the computer lab more hours

36.   More user-initiated services developed

37.   Provide color printing capabilities

38.   More computers for patrons and student workers in Reference Area

39.   Systematize services for distance students 

40.   Patron-initiated requesting of books through Aleph

41.   Adopt customer service pledge/program

42.   Staff should wear identification badges--"May I help you?"

43.   Improve outreach to undergraduates and graduate students

44.   More reliance on commercial document delivery as opposed to ILL reliance

45.   Improve outreach services to faculty

46.   Targeted effort at rapport building with faculty to increase awareness of current collections and services and enable University Libraries to better understand and respond to changing faculty needs.

47.   If research funding is negatively affected by continued economic challenges, there may be greater need to rely on reference librarians for assistance with research

48.   Faculty perception of University Libraries’ services influences the entire Notre Dame user community, positively or negatively

49.   The Workshop atmosphere provides a safe arena for overcoming and correcting negative impressions of University Libraries’ services and fosters a collaborative environment.

50.   Institute a program where every library faculty member is a subject librarian/liaison to increase communication between the library and patrons

51.   Customer service training for all staff to better interact with patrons, community, wealth of services and resources

52.   Offer reference services, for example, to assist with research; find ways to contribute uniquely

53.   Provide document delivery service to all University faculty, students, and staff

54.   Institute current awareness service for the campus

55.   Consider going back to paging service

56.   Balance* time/efforts on collections vs. time/efforts on services for those collections

57.   Discover more ways to package our resources into services like commercial institutions

58.   Provide librarian liaison for all the Universities dormitories

59.   Develop and activate reserve module in Aleph

60.   Survey of patrons regarding preference of print vs. electronic serials

 

I.  Get the Libraries Administration involved in library-wide efforts

1.       Establish quality standards and accountability:  follow through what is started

2.       Reduce meetings and committees!

3.       Educate staff on library procedures

4.       Group departments together

5.       Less paperwork, especially staff evaluations

6.       Set attainable goals and time frame

7.       Reward those who support the vision

8.       Aleph reports--statistics in a manageable or manipulative database

9.       Update and "maintained" printed library policies and procedures manual

10.   Join Digital Library Federation

11.   Clear expectations

12.   Statistics for use of Web site including branches

13.   Communicate to staff a synopsis of results of strategic planning process

14.   Library should have a living plan, both strategic and tactical

15.   Nice to know that the library knows what its position is on campus; should be working together

16.   Prioritize--can' do everything; do what we do well; have a plan

17.   Rarely articulate explicitly what we can't do; plan should add something and take away something even if it steps on people's dream projects; we can't do more with what we have

18.   Administrators/ADs help smooth the process, improve workflow, make the library more efficient

19.   Administrators/ADs bring depts. together to help us work better/more efficiently; cross-unit work

20.   Administrators/ADs actively helping to "unglue things"; make projects more clear--can't hope that people will work together

21.   Depts./staff may need to be more flexible about their areas of work

22.   Reverse trend of creating more and more small management units--should be broader, less focused groups; created situation with "too many chiefs, not enough Indians."; sucked into too may administrative responsibilities

23.   Less productive except as administrators

24.   Overspecialized, territorial, boredom, cliques

25.   Parallel to problems of big organizations, e.g., Johnson & Johnson which was improved by breaking down into smaller companies

26.   Need a mission plan

27.   Need to prioritize, help with marketing

28.   Identify/recognize/reposition staff based on strengths; good, hard look at what we're all good at; what part do we play in the whole?

29.   Be able to provide good, hard management data to improve decision making (both external and internal data)

30.   Understand each others roles for getting things done; being able to refer people to other places within the library

31.   What is the big picture?--but needs to be articulated in a way that everyone can relate to; lack data to provide it

32.   Management held accountable for decisions made (have data to make decisions; make decisions based on data) "that's what Harvard does"

33.   Repositioning people for positions of the future; but have to worry about how it affects people; slow to react to obvious trends--what until people are desperate; lack of understanding of how long things take

34.   Afraid to hire because it's difficult to take the position away

35.   Tend to be cautious which may be a good thing (e.g., do not want an eight-track player expert); difficult to predict, but can base jobs on skill sets

36.   Focus is on patrons of today, but not those of 5, 10, 15 years from now--need to focus more on the future

37.   Hire or consult with a professional futurist; consult the Futurist magazine

38.   Aleph support expanded to get more done in a timely manner--Aleph has much to offer, but needs setting up

39.   Must have staff accountability--is staff used efficiently?

40.   Let people know what is expected of them

41.   Consistent policy for all libraries regarding holidays, football weekends, etc.

42.   Pick up lost and found articles once a week

43.   Decide what the monitor's job is--job is located with an information desk, control of the door, or stop for security?

44.   Have rules and policing of patrons who are not students--at night, early morning, unsavory people

45.   Change use of library during football weekends; change hours

46.   Reevaluate committees' purposes--if none, then disband

47.   Establish written policy for when feds arrive

48.   Revive LPPs

49.   Enforce food and drink policy

50.   Allow food and drink in library

51.   Will lose users if the no food and drink policy is enforced

52.   Training to improve committee effectiveness

53.   Higher security for library staff--making fuller use of IDs

54.   Require that committees produce final reports

55.   Limit committee members' terms to one year

56.   Have a library-wide set of priorities

57.   Adopt a decision-making style that we are willing to follow

58.   Seek input from stakeholders when groups make decisions

59.   Make libraries more conducive to study, e.g., by enforcing quiet

60.   Improve relationships with areas libraries, e.g., schools, public, college

61.   Establish policy about cell phones, pagers, other noisemaking devices

62.   Provide more annual goals to committees that remain after the number of committees has been reduced

63.   Create a culture of assessment

64.   Provide regular round of visits by library administration to depts.

65.   Establish less corporate atmosphere

66.   Compare ourselves/visit the best academic libraries in the world (the best in whatever we think our deficiencies are)

67.   Create and foster more collaborative projects between fellow libraries

68.   Work as a library, not as depts. in a library

69.   Make steps to avoid becoming café

70.   Move towards process to minimize paper use

71.   Preservation--move from threat to opportunity

72.   Develop infrastructure for digitization

73.   Evaluate core level of public services

74.   Increase size of library faculty for instruction

75.   Rethink binding of currently received periodicals

76.   Prioritize obligations of the public service personnel to the campus vs. the non-campus communities

77.   Hire more people in Serials

78.   Recognize new projects need more resources

79.   More structure, appropriate timing for technology hardware deployment--staff, faculty, public

80.   Plan Aleph changes to optimize public rollout

81.   Develop disaster preparedness

82.   Increase Systems staff

83.   Employ archivist

84.   Resources for preservation of Special Collections

 

J.  Focus on improving working conditions, training, etc.

1.             Monthly event for staff to meet each other

2.             Periodic extra hour paid lunch break

3.             Fewer staff classification levels, but higher levels

4.             Improve library staff/faculty training

5.             Scholarship for staff to pursue library science degree

6.             Fund and recruit more technical support staff and more training

7.             Funding for non-exempt staff to attend conference, workshops, continuing education

8.             Cross-training staff to understand rest of library

9.             Do not lose human touch

10.         Improve morale

11.         More flex-time, even work at home

12.         More staff recognition and incentives for development

13.         Increase in-house education

14.         Library gather input from staff on where library is going, i.e., automation, procurement, innovations, pilot projects; include staff in vision planning

15.         Develop career path interest at staffing level, training, some jobs require localized training preferably through a class

16.         Encourage through incentives, development of skills, salary, days off

17.         Develop a hiring plan, anticipating retirees, set priorities, look at skill sets, certification requirements for faculty, upgrading current staff to fill those positions--recognize and develop current staff

18.         More classes offered for staff, different classes, more variety

19.         Human resources for the libraries alone, a generalist

20.         More current awareness of other branches and training/training for frontline staff for more integration of all libraries/branches

21.         Build incentive plan to have goals, friendlier atmosphere, new programs to prevent being stagnate--bring new ideas, techniques to jobs, better work flow; see how other colleges approach things

22.         Find a way to utilize current staff/students/graduate students' untapped abilities

23.         Could be using students to help (makes their work more valuable/relevant)

24.         If we are going to develop something dynamic, we will need more resources, staff, rewards

25.         Do we need more people and resources to improve services (otherwise, we’re "stuck")

26.         All staff (not just supervisors) have opportunities to grow besides in technology--additional to human resources

27.         If building is open 24 hours, need staff and librarians for periodicals, A/V, reference, reserves, public services areas Cross-training between areas so you know what other units do--a better understanding

28.         Daycare for staff that work in the evening

29.         Parking for those who must work on game days

30.         Place for staff and patrons in the library for lunch, e.g., Decio, De Grasta--hard to fight crowds in LaFortune

31.         Increase library staffing--increase things to do to get work done in timely and accurate ways

32.         Higher classification for library staff; higher entry-level because you need more knowledge to start

33.         Staff meetings and communication between supervisors and staff--need time arranged to meet

34.         Encourage staff to attend communication meetings--maybe they do not feel they know enough or can contribute

35.         Staff may feel they cannot advance--HR says must change position to advance

36.         Tap into strengths of staff beyond job description

37.         HR does not understand library functions and all that is involved with library work

38.         Public services areas are a lower level classification than other units

39.         Monitor parking in the Library Lot to keep unauthorized people out

40.         Bring spouse/date to recognition and award events

41.         Sit-down picnic, but not in August, stuffy in the Joyce

42.         More get-togethers to meet folks (hard to meet everyone in the library)

43.         Another library shirt (e.g., bar-coding shirt and recent shirt)

44.         More specific job training (getting general training now)--focus on individual's niches, more training for frontline staff ("ants")

45.         Address football weekends and their staffing problems--might be best to close the library; cannot get students, number of patrons low, parking problems for staff; helpful to see justification besides bathroom space

46.         Designate parking for staff on football weekends 

47.         Improve parking arrangement in the library circle

48.         Separate position classification for library staff--no level 3s, because of knowledge required

49.         Orientation for new University faculty, done in groups, especially for things like the A/V Center

50.         Picnic bench close to the library

51.         New file cabinets--mismatched sets make work difficult

52.         More exciting, new, different, tour for new employees; timing is poor--better during intersessions; could be shortened, too much; no surveys of supervisors; not enough time for some units; might include campus tour

53.         Upgrade in salary for library employees--review of classifications

54.         New equipment, furniture, shelving carts--more carts, and more space to keep them

55.         Better restroom facilities--more, cleaner, brighter--filthy now

56.         Review of levels to match importance of work

57.         Place for staff during all of building's hours--open the lounge at night

58.         More training for employees, especially Internet

59.         Nice employee lounge/café out of main part of building

60.         Provide recreation room for staff

61.         Better hours/shorter shifts for staff

62.         Better benefits/sick pay/compensation for holidays

63.         Free child care center

64.         Computer lab for staff and ND employees to use on non-work time

65.         Switch pay periods to every other week instead of monthly

66.         Provide training and development opportunities to staff

67.         Reevaluate staff positions in the library

68.         Increase staff salaries to improve morale

69.         Provide shuttle transportation for staff from parking lots

70.         Add move diverse librarians and staff, e.g., African-American Studies librarian

71.         Eliminate merit increases and find more fair way to increase staff salaries

72.         Add base salary increases yearly to reflect cost of living to staff salaries plus merit on top

73.         Hire more library faculty, and more diverse, too

74.         Fewer committees and committee meetings

75.         Evaluate staffing need of depts.

76.         Involve staff in more committees wherever possible

77.         Inform staff when committees are being formed so staff know how to be involved

78.         Expand new employee campus orientation to include campus tour

79.         Establish fund to send staff for MLS (also, time off)

80.         More parties, e.g., picnics

81.         Create a "buddy" program for new employees so information is given immediately

82.         Include symbols of Hesburgh library building in library tours

83.         Take in-depth look at insurance benefits that continue to cost more than the raise in salaries

84.         One-on-one staff-to-staff cross-training between units that are related

85.         Improve technology to support staff's true needs

86.         Give birthday off to staff without using vacation time

87.         Bring in masseuse

88.         Add ice machine in the lounge

89.         Clearer guidelines for library faculty promotion

90.         Communicate positive activities that happen in depts., etc. (recognition)

91.         Staff recognition once a month

92.         Seriously reconsider having a performance driven culture

93.         Bring back University staff newsletter in print

94.         Create a program or plan for staff so that everybody understands how what they do affects the University community we serve

95.         Form committee that helps keep up morale

96.         Follow through on salary expectations in order to keep morale high while continuing to provide excellent service.  Matrix did not raise all to market value, and current increases fall behind cost of living and market value.  HR and Libraries administration say one thing, but do not do it.  Salary increases are not in line with Bureau of Labor Statistics figures

97.         Adequate staffing to support expanded services

98.         Encourage and support staff to attend conferences other than ALA

99.         Support library faculty with professional development efforts; provide position description for guidance, protection

100.      Provide personnel management training/assistance for faculty--no direct line from HR to help with this area and local issues

101.      Would like to see upward evaluation/formal feedback of managers from staff

102.      Switch job days--familiar on other jobs

103.      Rethink workflow/business in general

104.      Gear the staff to accept continued change in work processes

105.      More classes on Aleph

106.      All ADs talk about change with staff time/flexibility

107.      Accurate up to date position descriptions for faculty and staff

108.      Develop unrestricted funds for staff development, rewards, etc.

109.      More training on Aleph

110.      Staff salaries up to market

111.      Better opportunities for job growth

112.      Library picnic days for meeting each other

113.      Promote job sharing specifically on special projects

114.      Feel for projects that are good and not so good

115.      Programs to improve staff morale

116.      New furniture for staff

117.      Encourage staff to participate in grant writing

118.      Training--new technologies that are coming up

119.      Incentive program for staff to participate in development

 

K.  Improve the library as a place

1.             Change library's look and feel

2.             Wood panels on ends of stacks

3.             Provide a place to relate to our co-workers

4.             Improve working conditions! (light, air, furniture)

5.             Venetian blinds in 208!  Windows everywhere

6.             Rare Books/Special Collections need separate and proper climate control

7.             Cleaning stacks of dust (the books and shelves)

8.             Plan for, implement off-site storage, consortium with other institutions

9.             Improve appearance and décor of 221

10.         Improve signage

11.         New HVAC for whole library, can be individually controlled

12.         Better meeting rooms just for staff and faculty

13.         No orange partitions--up-to-date color scheme; newer dividers

14.         E-conference facilities

15.         More quiet places to study

16.         Enlarge circulation desk

17.         Install shower

18.         Furnishings and cleaning products that are people friendly (non-allergenic)

19.         More space for science and a separate library

20.         Remove card catalog

21.         More attractive new book display on first floor

22.         Information commons

23.         Special Collections on 14th floor

24.         Nice art in library to attract visitors

25.         Ensure that all of our resources are accessible for people with handicaps including visual--requires cooperation with outside vendors to make sure their products are accessible--local vendors, too

26.         Off-site pageable storage (i.e., easily accessible)

27.         Get next phase of renovation focused on staff needs, comfortable, with facilities conducive to ongoing training and learning, adequate/dedicated space for collaborative work

28.         Invest large scale spending in renovation beyond current renovation, create more comfortable and inviting areas for public/patrons/staff

29.         Make library more beautiful, improved, enhanced 

30.         Provide good study areas

31.         Collaborative work spaces in library for patrons

32.         Chemistry/Physics library remodeled, renovated, and enlarged

33.         Engineering and Life Sciences libraries, remodeled, renovated, and enlarged

34.         Enclosed passageway between libraries so patrons are not exposed to elements

35.         Preservation friendly HVAC for all libraries

36.         Make libraries a destination for users, make more comfortable through better physical design

37.         Build centralized science and engineering library

38.         Renovation completed--clean building; easy access, bathrooms, 1st Floor

39.         Better equipment throughout library to bring in more students

40.         Provide location that inspires scholarship and encourages student/faculty interaction

41.         Build music library

42.         As part of renovation, reconfigure and update HVAC for enhancement to protect collection and for comfort of staff

43.         Improving signage

44.         Information commons (meeting place)/collaborative teaching projects

45.         Improve building's atmosphere/feel--"all angular"

46.         More windows (lack of natural light)

47.         Have something that draws the students to the physical space--should be inviting; this would help funding efforts--"looks the same as 20 years ago"

48.         Working on improving the work space/physical proximity to make thing more cohesive for working units

49.         Library as place to meet other colleagues/other people/research assistance; must be inviting, have plenty of meeting rooms, etc, e.g., Border's

50.         Paint the books because the books look old and shabby

51.         Off-site retrievable storage

52.         Branch libraries need more space

53.         Centralized science library

54.         Seldom used books to go to off-site storage

55.         Take downs flags/banners in the Hesburgh concourse

56.         Get rid of outdated signs, etc.

57.         More comfortable library, comfortable seating--currently is signals, don't stay very long

58.         Update staff furniture, all furniture

59.         Update circulation work station and window coverings

60.         Library looks tacky, dirty--freshen up!

61.         Ugly/inefficient book bins at return area

62.         Holes in carpet for electrical work; patch to cover

63.         More welcoming environment

64.         Better restrooms, cleaner

65.         Displays in the concourse should be library related

66.         Heat the building uniformly

67.         Windows cleaned on all floors (especially 12th) for picture taking

68.         Remove old stuff in the concourse, UNLOC banners, employee of the year, etc.

69.         Put something in the big display cases that have nothing in them

70.         Look for something, e.g., café, to help make this library attractive, make it the center of the campus, especially with functions on the 14th floor

71.         Remote, accessible storage for older, non-circulating items--make available in microformat, digitize to improve preservation; out of space for new materials

72.         More welcoming environment, especially concourse, does not look like you are in library

73.         More room for books

74.         Music should have its own library

75.         Privacy booths in A/V for viewing

76.         Carpet in A/V to reduce noise, increase safety

77.         Create an Information Desk--where to get change, bathrooms, etc.

78.         Carpet to reduce noise throughout the library, by elevators to mask the noise from the shelving carts

79.         More inviting space, more friendly--too sanitized

80.         Provide handicapped access to all bathrooms

81.         Bathroom better located on 1st Floor--open to public

82.         Building open more, especially in public service areas; staffed by staff and librarians, not students

83.         Private study rooms nicer

84.         Re-do plumbing and painting--new tile in bathroom

85.         Sliding doors need methods so they do not jam in winter--cover or canopy outside would help

86.         Doors to library proper need to be open--patrons don’t find reference area/desk

87.         Remove dead plants/get more live ones

88.         Unnecessary for library to be open 24 hours

89.         Do not use carpet or padded chairs in food service areas in the library

90.         Access to water supply on 1st Floor

91.         More water fountains

92.         Get rid of ancient turn-stiles

93.         14th Floor renovation should look nice

94.         Make view available from 13th Floor so people can see the campus (wall of windows)

95.         Improve parking situation

96.         Provide better handicapped parking

97.         More accessible reference and circulation areas

98.         Improve location of computer lab--used often

99.         Increase cleaning staff on football weekends

100.      Clean windows in the tower

101.      Clean library--do workers need more supervision?; should be supervised more because of high use in library

102.      Computer desks and chairs are too low for adults in the 2nd Floor computer lab

103.      Cafeteria--separate place for staff and students to eat

104.      Picnic area outside library

105.      People don’t feel welcome with gates--not comfortable going through turnstile and security watching them

106.      More undergraduate study space with ResNet or wireless connections

107.      24 hour access to building

108.      Provide an off-campus storage (air-conditioned) to store books

109.      Provide dedicated classroom space in library

110.      More modern look for Hesburgh library, including café or coffee shop

111.      Offer more group study space for collaboration in research

112.      Emphasize preservation of physical collection

113.      Keep cleaner library space--too dusty

114.      Add moveable shelving to Tower

115.      Spend more funding on making library more inviting, e.g., plants, art work

116.      Add lockers for students

117.      Expand Life Science library

118.      Make Government Documents work area bigger and more ergonomically correct

119.      Update library décor to be cozier and more inviting

120.      Be resourceful in creating more inviting physical environment in Hesburgh Library

121.      Current partitions are forbidding and give the impression, especially to neophytes, that access is only for “authorized persons”.

122.      Dispose of some of the tables piling up around Hesburgh. Can user space be defined in terms of dedicated square feet rather than the number of tables available? With increasing use of laptops, there is little need for these clunky pieces and they take up room and make the area seem very crowded

123.      If funds permitted, it would be nice to build a new state of the art patron service area, perhaps adjacent to and connected to Hesburgh Library. This area could house user services and provide user-friendly study space and a generally attractive environment

124.      Up-grade quality and uniformity of signage and visual environment, in Hesburgh library at least. Someone needs to go through on a regular basis with a critical eye, or we need to have an on-line suggestion box for these little details. Lots of little homemade signs get put up and stay up without review or renewal. The knotted plastic tape closing off the stairway to the basement is unsightly, particularly since the barrier is going to be up for a long time. The fake flowers and angel under the sculpture in the Hesburgh foyer are incongruous. The placement of the book-sale now in the Reference area of Hesburgh is inappropriate, as it looks tacky and is the first thing you see as you come into that area; it takes up a valuable location. (How about against the south wall by the approval room door?) The sanitary disposal cans in the Hesburgh tower ladies' rooms are rusty, battered and broken. Etc., etc.

125.      Keep the renovation going--do not stop with the basement

126.      Library is uninviting, restrictive, appears closed to ideas, stale, old, and it affects the work we do (same as 10 years ago)

127.      Take the old turn stiles away

128.      More color, texture, contrast, plants--library is visually monotonous, not cozy, not inviting

129.      Build cyber cafe for laptops, coffee, and access to the library

130.      Put in a coffee shop

131.      Use whole tower for books

132.      Small, state of the art place that is separate, cozy, etc., for primary public service areas

133.      Improve HVAC

134.      Restrooms on 1st Floor

135.      Better cleaning system

136.      Get rid of new photocopiers

137.      More risks to weed collection

138.      Create comfortable and appealing library environment

139.      Move more material off site--one day retrieval

140.      Improve environment for storage of collections

141.      Improve Hesburgh HVAC

142.      Commercial or approved off site storage

143.      Quality of patron study space be improved

144.      More art work on walls--ND students

145.      Finish renovation as quickly as possible

146.      Café in library

147.      Plan for science facility to ease overcrowding

148.      Improve exhibit space for Special Collections

149.      Renovation:  segregate user and collection spaces

150.      Build new library

151.      Renovation space plan needs re-examination, specifically serials space inadequate

152.      Renovation:  restore all office space

153.      Open 14th Floor

154.      Ice machine for staff kitchen